BBC NEWSAmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia PacificArabicSpanishRussianChineseWelsh
BBCiCATEGORIES  TV  RADIO  COMMUNICATE  WHERE I LIVE  INDEX   SEARCH 

BBC NEWS
 You are in: Education
News image
Front Page 
World 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Hot Topics 
UK Systems 
League Tables 
Features 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 
News image


Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

SERVICES 
Thursday, 24 January, 2002, 11:56 GMT
Colleges despair at exam board 'error'
The problem maths paper
The organisation representing colleges has renewed its attack on exam board Edexcel, accusing it of having published an unanswerable "model" maths question.

And a former examiner with the board said the errors were "a disaster waiting to happen".

The Association of Colleges (AoC) was critical of the board earlier this week, during the fuss over an AS-level maths paper which had an error in a diagram.

The two organisations are supposed to be working together to address concerns about the board raised by colleges in a survey last summer.

But now the association has chosen to publicise a specimen paper on Edexcel's website containing a question which cannot be answered for want of information.

The exam board is likely to respond with a strongly-worded letter.

Momentum problem

Some news reports about last Friday's problematic maths question referred to that as "unanswerable", but Edexcel later pointed out that two thirds of the 2,500 candidates had managed to get the answer right.

This case is different.

The question is on the GCE Maths AS-level Unit MI (Mechanics) specimen paper. It is dated January 2000 and was published the following month.

Question five refers to two objects colliding and fusing and asks what would happen to the resulting object.

It cannot be answered because the speed of one of the objects before the collision is not given.

News imageClick here for the question.

An AoC spokeswoman said: "In setting up their stall in this way they are demonstrating the very point they are seeking to deny - which is that they can't get the questions right."

The AoC's director of further education development, Dr John Brennan, said the matter raised concerns about Edexcel's quality assurance.


I could see that this was a disaster waiting to happen

Anne Rickwood, former Edexcel examiner
The association's director of curriculum and quality, Judith Norrington, said: "It seems extraordinary that Edexcel cannot quality assure the model questions on their own website, which unfortunately only confirms the anxieties which colleges around the country have expressed to us for the last year."

The authority has been asked by the Education Secretary, Estelle Morris, to publish its latest routine audit of Edexcel as soon as possible.

'Disaster waiting to happen'

The former head of the international department at Edexcel, Anne Rickwood, said she had foreseen the board might run into difficulties before she left in 1999.

"I could see that this was a disaster waiting to happen," she said.

Ms Rickwood said exam boards became increasingly competitive and market-orientated after the launch of the National Curriculum.

But a competitive culture was not appropriate because of the volume and intensity of work involved, she said.

"If you have departments competing with each other, there are going to be black holes into which things can fall, such as we see happening now."

Action plan

Staff at Edexcel have spent most of the week investigating a host of similar queries.

A spokeswoman said most of these had turned out to be "salacious" - such as the Devon students' course work supposedly lost by the exam board, which turned up in a college store room.

She said Edexcel had agreed a nine-point action plan with the AoC to improve its services to colleges.

This included having two college representatives on Edexcel's council and setting up a further education forum, which is due to meet for the first time next month.

"Therefore we are surprised that they have raised this now," she added.

The question - if wrong - would be removed from the website.


A truck of mass 3 tonnes moves on straight horizontal rails. It collides with truck B of mass 1 tonne, which is moving on the same rails. Immediately before the collision, the speed of A is 3 ms-1 and the trucks are moving towards each other. In the collision, the trucks couple to form a single body C, which continues to move on the rails.

(a) Find the speed and direction of C after the collision. (4 marks)
(b) Find, in Ns, the magnitude of the impulse exerted by B on A in the collision. (3 marks)
(c) State a modelling assumption which you have made about the trucks in your solution (1 mark)

Immediately after the collision, a constant braking force of magnitude 250 N is applied to C. It comes to rest in a distance d metres.

(d) Find the value of d. (4 marks)

News imageBack to main text

 WATCH/LISTEN
 ON THIS STORY
News image Dr John Brennan, Association of Colleges
"This raises questions about quality assurance"
News image Former Edexcel examiner Anne Rickwood
"This was bound to happen"
See also:

22 Jan 02 | Education
Call for exam board to be sacked
22 Jan 02 | Education
More errors blamed on exam board
21 Jan 02 | Education
Examiners knew about maths error
22 Jan 02 | Education
Q&A: Edexcel
18 Dec 01 | Education
Exams repeated mock questions
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Education stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Education stories



News imageNews image