BBC HomepageWorld ServiceEducation
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Education
News image
Front Page 
World 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Hot Topics 
UK Systems 
League Tables 
Features 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 
News image



The BBC's Jon Brain
"Accident investigators had found holes in the boat"
 real 56k

Thursday, 7 June, 2001, 16:52 GMT 17:52 UK
'Neglect' verdict on drowned schoolgirl
Elizabeth and Victoria Bee
Elizabeth Bee, on the left, was on the trip with her sister, Victoria
An inquest jury has returned a verdict of accidental death contributed to by neglect on nine-year-old Elizabeth Bee, who drowned during a school boating trip in Portsmouth harbour.

The seven men and four women had been told by Portsmouth coroner James Kenroy that a finding of neglect would entail the "gross failure" of a teacher on the trip "to provide basic attention to the young girl".

Elizabeth and her twin sister Victoria were with seven other children and their 64-year-old teacher when their boat capsized in September 1999.

Elizabeth became trapped underneath the hull of the boat, while the other children and the teacher were thrown clear.
Paul Dove
Teacher Paul Dove said conditions were reasonable

The hearing had heard that the teacher - Paul Dove - did not do a proper headcount and that Elizabeth was only discovered after her sister realised she was missing.

First aid was given but she died in hospital.

Her father said after the inquest that he was satisfied with the result.

But he added: "This is not finished yet. We are still going to carry on.

"There are avenues which we can go through because I am still not entirely happy with some of the issues."

Her mother, Lesley, 44, said through tears: "I am really, really pleased at last that somebody has taken the blame. I can now draw a line underneath it all.

"Elizabeth has not lost her life in vain. This should never happen again. I have just wanted someone to put their hands up and say, it's our fault."

dory boat which capsized
The dory capsized, trapping Elizabeth underneath
"During the three-day hearing, the inquest was told that under guidelines on school trips, another teacher should have been on board the boat to watch the children.

Conditions had been bad on the day that the pupils, from the independent Boundary Oak School in Fareham, Hampshire, set out for a sailing trip at the Royal Navy's Sailing Club at Whale Island in Portsmouth.

A total of 18 children went to the sailing centre, accompanied by two teachers and a gap year student.

Conditions in the morning were too bad to sail, but the decision was taken in the afternoon to take a small party out, although the wind was still force four to five.

The teacher, Paul Dove, set off with the nine children in a flat-bottomed boat known as a dory, which was 14ft long.

Teacher's statement

In a statement, Paul Dove told the inquest that he had thought conditions were reasonable.

"I judged conditions not to be appropriate for sailing especially for beginners. But a short excursion of the sailing area in the dory was agreed upon," the statement said.

"I wanted to show the children where the sailing would take place.

"The children were already kitted in wetsuits and life jackets and were keen to get out on to the water."

The inquest heard that during the lesson one child had fallen overboard and another had been stung by a jellyfish.

The engine also stalled twice and it was shortly after the second attempt to restart the motor that the boat capsized.

Mr Dove said: "It may have been five minutes from when the engine stalled to when the boat capsized. I found myself in the water and swam back to the boat.

"Most of the children were sat on the hull and some of the children were blowing whistles.

"I called out to the children to see if they were all there and they shouted that they were."

Rescuers

Rescuers called out to the scene told the inquest also gave evidence.

Rescuer David Baker said he had seen the boat shortly before it capsized and had been surprised that the small craft had been taken out in such windy conditions.

He said: "The wind in the morning had been about 20 to 22 knots - at 30 knots ferries have to be assisted into their berths by tugs.

"I was surprised that dory was out in those gusty conditions. I have seen boats sink in similar conditions."

The coroner, James Kenroy, had told the jury of seven men and four women that Elizabeth had died after it had been assumed nothing could go wrong.

"I would look to the Titanic for a classic illustration, in that the impossible must be planned for," he said.

News imageSearch BBC News Online
News image
News image
News imageNews image
Advanced search options
News image
Launch console
News image
News image
News imageBBC RADIO NEWS
News image
News image
News imageBBC ONE TV NEWS
News image
News image
News imageWORLD NEWS SUMMARY
News image
News image
News image
News image
News imageNews imageNews imageNews imagePROGRAMMES GUIDE
See also:

17 Jan 00 | Education
Schools warned of farm trip risks
12 Oct 98 | Education
Safety tips on school trips
11 Apr 01 | Education
Manslaughter teacher to appeal
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Education stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Education stories



News imageNews image