It's a blanket approach which needs to be re-thought by the government

David Hart

Earlier this month the Universities Council for the Education of Teachers - which represents 87 UK universities and colleges involved in teacher education - warned it was "madness" to risk losing good candidates at a time of teacher shortages.

The National Association of Head Teachers agrees that the tests are not working and must be changed.

"There is a lack of sophistication about the whole business," said general secretary, David Hart.

"It's a blanket approach which needs to be re-thought by the government," he said.

Head teacher, Liz Paver, said up to 60% of those present - journalists and head teachers - for the discussion would probably fail the test.

Introducing the tests at the start of a PGSE course would go a long way to avoid unnecessary disappointment, she added.

A-level standard

Outgoing NAHT president, Mick Brookes, said the numeracy test was pitched too high and was close to A-level standard.

The tests would do nothing to attract students into the profession, he added.

Incoming NAHT president, Sue Sayles, said: "We need to get the passion back into teaching."

"We need to get A-level students thinking 'yes, I want to be a teacher'."

A passion test might be more appropriate than a numeracy test, she joked.

But a senior government spokesman insisted the tests were necessary and that there were no plans to scrap them.

Recruitment problems

The government must acknowledge there was a problem in teacher recruitment, Mr Hart said.

"What we need is honesty from the in-coming government. We need them to say 'yes, there is a problem'.

"We lose far too many teachers in the first few years and many at the golden age of 50."

While the union was not a supporter of a 35-hour week, reducing teachers' workload was the most important factor in recruitment and retention, Mr Hart said.

An extra 40,000 teachers were needed to redress the balance of work on teachers, he said.

"It's all about giving teachers decent terms of service."