EuropeSouth AsiaAsia PacificAmericasMiddle EastAfricaBBC HomepageWorld ServiceEducation
News image
News image
News image
News imageNews image
News image
Front Page
News image
World
News image
UK
News image
UK Politics
News image
Business
News image
Sci/Tech
News image
Health
News image
Education
News image
Sport
News image
Entertainment
News image
Talking Point
News image
In Depth
News image
On Air
News image
Archive
News image
News image
News image
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help
News imageNews imageNews image
Monday, September 27, 1999 Published at 11:32 GMT 12:32 UK
News image
News image
UK
News image
Head to head: Gays in the military
News image

News image
The European Court of Human Rights may have ruled that the ban on gays in the UK armed forces is a breach of human rights, but that doesn't change the arguments for those involved.

Here General Sir Anthony Farrar-Hockley argues that morale and discipline will be affected by the ruling while Angela Mason, spokeswoman for Stonewall, heralds the decision.


[ image: ]

General Sir Anthony Farrar-Hockley:

The European Court of Human Rights has ruled that the British Armed Forces are obliged to enlist avowed homosexuals. Wittingly or otherwise, this decision will strike at morale and discipline.

The court's assumption is that military employments are much the same as others. But they are not.

The services are recruited and trained for war fighting. In this function death or wounds are a regular outcome. Those engaged are obliged to operate in close groups for long periods; comradeship is the binding factor. Ata a time when homogeneity is essential, sexual squabbles will be disruptive. Perhaps fatally so.


News imageNews image
The BBC's Graham Satchell: "The Government policy of banning gay men and women is now in tatters"
The fragmentary but noisy sexual lobby asks 'why should Britain stand alone in this matter?'. It does not. For example, the United States forces - principally regular - have a clear policy. Recruiters do not ask and individuals do not tell whether they are gay or not.

Two surveys have disclosed that the overwhelming majority of those in military service today find homosexuality abhorrent.

They resent the rejection of their opinion as valueless and question how far this form of change will lead. Are transsexuals and transvestites to be admitted?

Wellington's remarks about some of his soldiers may have a new application: "I don't know whether they will scare the enemy, but they certainly frighten me."
[ image: ]



[ image: ]

Angela Mason, spokesperson for the lesbian and gay rights group Stonewall:

The Court of Human Rights has condemned the government witch-hunts against lesbians and gays in the military. Men and women, with exemplary military records, who have been hunted down, endured humiliating interrogations and dismissed solely because of their sexuality, will finally win compensation.

The days of the ban are over.

News imageNews image
News image
This is good news for everybody. The armed forces are desperately short of recruits. It makes no sense to dismiss highly trained personnel. Lifting the ban will not make the armed services one bit less effective. You don't have to be heterosexual to shoot straight!

Lifting the ban now will save a lot of money. If the government ignore the decision of the European Court the taxpayers bill could rise to over �6 million.

There are those who claim, including the Ministry of Defence that, men and women in the British forces are somehow uniquely prejudiced -that they would refuse to serve with lesbians and gay men. I believe that this is in an insult. A new NOP poll, published last week, shows that 68% of the population thought the ban should be lifted, including 58% of Tories.

The case of John Beckett, who served in the Royal Navy and is now a policeman in Sheffield, illustrates the point. John served in submarines living and working in close quarters with his heterosexual colleagues.

Nobody ever made any complaint about his behaviour. But when he told his chaplain that he had a gay civilian partner he was immediately dismissed. His commanding officer commented upon his efficiency, intelligence and dedication. We need people like John Beckett in the armed forces not out of it.

In East Timor the international peace keeping forces from Australia and New Zealand have no gay ban. Nor did the Dutch forces in Bosnia or the German and the French in Kosovo. Is anyone seriously saying that this makes them unfit to do the job?

In 1996 government lawyers advised Michael Portillo as Minister of Defence that the ban was a breach of the Convention of Human Rights. He chose to ignore that advice. It would be a disgrace if a Labour Government, which has passed the Human Rights Act, were to play the same game.
[ image: ]



News image


Advanced options | Search tips


News image
News image
News imageBack to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage |
News image

News imageNews imageNews image
UK Contents
News image
News imageNorthern Ireland
News imageScotland
News imageWales
News imageEngland
News imageNews image
Relevant Stories
News image
27 Sep 99�|�UK
Military gay ban illegal
News image
25 Sep 99�|�UK
Sacked gay Navy chef may sue MOD
News image
02 Aug 99�|�UK
Army backs sex-change soldiers
News image
19 May 99�|�UK
Gays armed forces ban 'inhumane'
News image
18 May 99�|�UK
Opposing views in gay debate
News image

News image
News image
News image
News imageInternet Links
News image
News imageNews image
Stonewall
News image
Rank Outsiders
News image
European Court of Human Rights
News image
Royal Navy
News image
Ministry of Defence
News image
News imageNews image
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

News image
News image
News image
News imageIn this section
News image
Next steps for peace
News image
Blairs' surprise over baby
News image
Bowled over by Lord's
News image
Beef row 'compromise' under fire
News image
Hamilton 'would sell mother'
News image
Industry misses new trains target
News image
From Sport
Quins fightback shocks Cardiff
News image
From Business
Vodafone takeover battle heats up
News image
IRA ceasefire challenge rejected
News image
Thousands celebrate Asian culture
News image
From Sport
Christie could get two-year ban
News image
From Entertainment
Colleagues remember Compo
News image
Mother pleads for baby's return
News image
Toys withdrawn in E.coli health scare
News image
From Health
Nurses role set to expand
News image
Israeli PM's plane in accident
News image
More lottery cash for grassroots
News image
Pro-lifers plan shock launch
News image
Double killer gets life
News image
From Health
Cold 'cure' comes one step closer
News image
From UK Politics
Straw on trial over jury reform
News image
Tatchell calls for rights probe into Mugabe
News image
Ex-spy stays out in the cold
News image
From UK Politics
Blair warns Livingstone
News image
From Health
Smear equipment `misses cancers'
News image
From Entertainment
Boyzone star gets in Christmas spirit
News image
Fake bubbly warning
News image
Murder jury hears dead girl's diary
News image
From UK Politics
Germ warfare fiasco revealed
News image
Blair babe triggers tabloid frenzy
News image
Tourists shot by mistake
News image
A new look for News Online
News image

News image
News image
News image