Skip to main contentAccess keys help

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
News image
Last Updated: Sunday, 26 October, 2003, 22:31 GMT
Row over racism film 'pressure'
Oliver Letwin
Mr Letwin warned of the dangers of unofficial censorship
The government must explain whether a top Home Office civil servant tried to get the BBC to shelve a documentary about police racism, the shadow home secretary has demanded.

Oliver Letwin was responding to the revelation on Sunday that John Gieve, permanent secretary at the Home Office, wrote to BBC chairman Gavyn Davies to complain about The Secret Policeman a month before it was broadcast.

The Observer newspaper said unnamed senior BBC executives viewed the move as an attempt to get the programme pulled.

A flurry of police resignations and suspensions followed the airing of the film, in which one policeman wore a mock Ku Klux Klan hood and insulted the parents of murdered black teenager Stephen Lawrence.

The functioning of a democracy cannot be taken for granted if the state seeks to exercise unofficial censorship
Oliver Letwin
Shadow home secretary
The Home Secretary David Blunkett initially attacked the methods used in the programme, calling it a "covert stunt", but later conceded the behaviour captured on film was "horrendous".

'Intervention'

The documentary was based on a seven-month undercover operation by BBC journalist Mark Daly, who joined Greater Manchester Police as a trainee officer.

The reporter was arrested on suspicion of obtaining a pecuniary advantage by deception and damaging police property. He is due to answer bail next month.

Mark Daly, who posed as a police recruit for the programme
We look to the police for protection, advice and security - it's for this reason I believe our investigation was justified
Mark Daly

On Sunday, Mr Letwin praised the BBC's "valuable role in uncovering sickening and intolerable examples of racism in that particular police force.

"It is therefore extremely disturbing to discover that attempts were made by the Home Office, at the highest level, to intervene in relation to this film some weeks before it was shown," he said.

Mr Letwin said he would table questions in parliament to find out the intent of the intervention.

"If the Home Office was not trying to keep the film off the air, what was it trying to do?" he said.

"We need a clear answer because the functioning of a liberal, tolerant and law-abiding democracy cannot be taken for granted if the state seeks to exercise unofficial censorship over important journalistic investigations."

'Diversion'

The Home Office confirmed Mr Gieve sent the letter on 12 September, but denied it was an attempt to force BBC bosses to axe the programme.

"John Gieve did not ask the BBC to pull the programme," a spokeswoman told BBC News Online.

"He was expressing concerns about the undercover methods used in it."

She accepted the programme had "raised serious issues, which we are acting swiftly to tackle".

A BBC spokesman said the corporation "does from time to time come under pressure from institutions or government bodies about the content of its investigative programmes.

"The BBC will not pull back from making demanding and challenging programmes."

He said this latest row only served to divert attention from the issues brought up in the film.

Crimewatch 'threat'

Sunday's Observer article also alleges that the chief constable of Greater Manchester Police told the BBC it risked a new "Hutton-style inquiry" if it went ahead with the broadcast.

Chief constable Mike Todd is said to have met with the BBC director-general Greg Dyke and other senior executives a week before the film went out.

He is alleged to have warned the BBC it risked destroying its relationship with the police.

He is also said to have threatened to withdraw police cooperation in the BBC1's Crimewatch programme.




SEE ALSO:
Can you test for racism?
22 Oct 03  |  UK


RELATED BBCi LINKS:

RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
AmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific