Bob Geldof has outlined his plans to repeat 1985's Live Aid concert this summer to coincide with the G8 summit and highlight global poverty.
Live 8 will take place in London's Hyde Park on 2 July with other concerts in the US, Paris, Rome and Berlin.
One of the aims is to raise awareness of Make Poverty History, a campaign to get the richest nations to cancel debt, increase aid and fairer trade rules for developing countries.
Will pressurising the world's leaders in this way have a greater impact than raising money would? Do you think Live 8 will make a difference? Would you want to go to any of the concerts?
This debate is now closed. Read a selection of your comments below.
The following comments reflect the balance of opinion we have received so far:
This will achieve nothing. We will look at this again in 20 years and they will still have begging bowls out and Sir Bob will be asking for us to partake in Live Age Concern for pensioners plights. Get real, Africa is a bottomless pit with fat cats at the top holding the money and power. Want to help Sir Bob? Reform the African governments. Don't whine to us.
Vince Scott, Birmingham, UK I'm afraid that Bob Geldof has gone too far with this Sail 8 "Cry". I was all for it but now it's becoming a farce. Yes we know that global poverty is a dilemma and let's face it, global just doesn't mean Africa. Millions of people marching on Edinburgh won't eradicate poverty it will just get people's backs-up. There has to be a joint political solution not whacky pop starts.
Pete B, Cambs, UK
I resent the fact that the leading spokesman on world poverty at the moment is Geldof; the western worlds love affair with celebrity only serves to reinforce the status quo, and doesn't really help those genuinely in need. I mean, how patronising is it to think that you can solve the problems in Africa with handouts?
Patrick S, London
This will raise awareness of the issue of global poverty for a while which is a positive, but not huge, benefit. I wonder how many people understand how Europe's theft of Africa for centuries has left it in the state it is in. I suspect the issue will die away again with very little having been done for the long-term. How long have we been hearing about the cancellation of Third World debt and still nothing's been done?
HR, London, UK
Too much emotion. Too little thought. Another massive energy wasting exercise that will do nothing to alleviate poverty in Africa! Let the leaders of Africa make their case then they will feel more obliged to conduct themselves with integrity and honour.
Tim Rollinson, Tonbridge, UK
I think it is marvellous that one of the richest, most pampered, self-absorbed and self-indulgent groups in society once again feel that it is time for them to give the rest of us the benefit of their collective political wisdom. Don't misunderstand me - I think that global poverty is a very important problem that the world must solve. I also think that it and its solution are too complicated to be solved by this stunt. It can only be solved by our elected representatives. It should not be an opportunity for aging pop stars and this week's pop sensations to indulge their latest fad, some of whom will no doubt be looking to cynically exploit this cause to prop-up their career/new album/public-image/ego.
Ian, Beverley, UK
 |  Cynicism never accomplished anything |
I don't understand why people are so very concerned about the pop stars massaging their egos. The younger generation in the western world today are very unaware of the situation in Africa. Twenty years ago this problem was brought to the public's attention; we have a new generation twenty years on that needs to be made aware. What they do with this information is up to them but if at the very least inspires some of the younger generation to choose to be a part of solving this problem professionally, then it has been a success. Cynicism never accomplished anything.
Sally, USA/UK Africa is like a man with two broken legs. When the TV crew is there and the cameras are rolling we give Africa a pair of crutches to help him stand up; that is our aid policy. When the camera is turned off and the TV crew goes away - we kick Africa in the shins and make him fall over again - that is our trade policy. If Live 8 can raise awareness of how the West keeps Africa poor by shutting them out of our markets, that can only be a good thing.
Teresa, London
The root cause of poverty is not being tackled, raising millions or billions in aid will not bring poverty to extinction. First tackle the corrupt officials and bring in clean transparent governments, then people can partake in ending poverty. Live 8 is of no benefit in the present state. What did the Band Aid concert 20 years ago achieve?? Learn from that.
M, Sutton Coldfield, UK
These sorts of events rarely seem to add up to much more than a way for people to feel they've 'done their bit' for the less fortunate. The real issues behind global poverty are never discussed frankly, because to do so would expose the G8 governments as the financial despots that they really are. The Third World is in the state it is because the first world went in, stole all the natural resources of the countries in question, suppressed the population to avoid the risk of revolution, and then, when public opinion made this untenable, offered them 'loans' from the IMF, designed to keep them in constant thrall to the first world. Mr Brown's ideas are laudable, and could go some way to helping the situation, but one can't help but see it as a PR ploy by a desperately unpopular Labour government who have already made themselves look like raptors.
Paul Raven, Southsea, UK
As the chairman of a pan-African ngo, I can say that this is a useless political plan. Remove trade barriers, open markets, remove old foreign debt and stop corrupted bribes for contracts Lead by example Western world, care more to avoid Rwanda again in Sudan and other parts. This concert is nothing more than a fun day out for millions in London. Why not do the same in Lagos, Nigeria or Lusaka Zambia. Or are the artists too VIP for that?
Julian Wood, Ibadan, Nigeria
It takes two to tango. I do not believe Live 8 is the only effective way to go. The emphasis must be placed on good governance. Let's put the corrupt African leaders on the spot; what do they have to offer?
Kotey J, Accra, Ghana
| Sending the money it would cost for the concert and all the promotions to Africa would be more beneficial |
Why highlight global poverty? We all know it exists, but concrete action needs to take place. Sending the money it would cost for the concert and all the promotions to Africa would be more beneficial. We need to help Africa stand on its own two feet, rather than keep giving them things for free.
Rachel, London All you cynics, I'm afraid have missed the point. This concert is not about Bob Geldof, what he has or hasn't done, but about the fact that people really do need a kick to do something. If the only way the populations of the richest countries will take any sort of interest in the dying children of the continent they have destroyed is to see pop bands then so be it. There is no way the men of the G8 will ignore the demands of five populations. They should, and eventually will demolish debt, this will mean the countries will have money to work with in the fight against Aids and rebuild an infrastructure.
Eleanor Fowler, Northumberland, England
If Bob Geldof and the others really cared they would give their own money or work with charities who work for relief of poverty. The proposed Live 8 concert is just an ego trip for him and the rest of those taking part. He has no right to tell others what to do. I hope Live 8 is a failure and maybe that would dent Bob Geldof's ego a bit but he would blame others for any failure. It would serve him right if no one turned up at the concerts. Why should Hyde Park, a haven for Londoners, be turned into a rubbish tip just to satisfy the egos of millionaire ex-popstars who have more money than they know what to do with.
R J H, London UK
Its brilliant what sir Bob Geldof is doing, but he is a small majority of the rich and famous who are trying to do something about the situation in Africa. The normal people in the UK are the ones who will end up paying to sort out the crisis. If only the rich would cut back on the luxuries they endure and put their money to better causes rather than having to use people's taxes to resolve the situation?
Caroline Waite, Blaenavon Wales
It seems Live 8 has already achieved something before the five concerts begin. Sir Bob's aim was to rid Africa of the debt burden first before fresh aid could reach the intended goals. Well, full marks to Sir Bob it looks like Britain is already pushing for the African debt to be written off. Let's hope we can convince world leaders to do the same!
Mike Neill, Hull, UK
The comments on this board really show how vital this is. So many people are so poorly educated about the problems in Africa and the reasons for them, so many people are willing to comment and say this will achieve nothing without understanding what it is set out to achieve. If people understood that the dropping of the debt meant people in Africa would stop having to pay for the mansions that past dictators built, the corruption that kept people in poverty and for the bullets that killed their loved ones then they would not allow the politicians not to drop the debt. Trade needs to be fair and aid needs to increase.
Rob, Manchester, UK
Of course it will make no difference. Those at the top of the tree want to stay there. Rich people get rich by taking advantage of those they consider to be "less worthy" than them. If the political will existed to change things, it would already have happened.
Colin Reynolds, Cambs, UK
It's hard not to be inspired by Bob Geldof's passionate advocacy, but then I look at Sudan, Ivory Coast, Equatorial Guinea, Zimbabwe and elsewhere, and wonder whether debt relief without regime change will simply allow corrupt leaders to spend more on buying weapons and enriching themselves.
David, London N1
Come on guys - have you not heard what's being said?! It is not about giving money. It is all about cancelling debt, making trade fair and ensuring governments use the extra capital that gives - plus any aid that gets there - in ways that will benefit their nations. It's not fair that in 2005 people are dying because they do not have enough to eat. It's not fair that people are dying because they have to use filthy water supplies instead of convenient taps. It's not fair that the people who grow the food we eat are forced to sell their produce at less than the cost of production. Come on Tony, Jacques, Vladimir, Gerhard, George, Junichiro, Silvio, Paul and Jose. You want a place in history? Then do it - make poverty history. We owe it to those who need our help the most.
Paul, Swindon, Wilts
| Pop and politics are poor bed fellows |
Well intentioned but pointless. Pop and politics are poor bedfellows - pop cannot change the world only nations themselves can do that.
R C Robjohn, UK
Hopefully Sir Bob and this concert will raise some further awareness into a situation, which if left unattended will come back to haunt us in more than one direction. In this materialistic world a little common sense and basic humanity would not go amiss.
Dave, England
It will achieve a feel good moment for delusional liberals. One can always hope that with the liberals giving money to African dictators, which in turn will be used to support further civil wars, oppression, slavery and land appropriation, the liberals will be feeling so virtuous they'll stop mucking up the rest of the world.
Hezi Golani, USA
It makes me very angry when people just criticise people like Bob Geldof. What are they doing to help anyone? It's time more people got of their backsides and 'did' something instead of just complaining about those who are at least trying to make a difference. Good on you Bob!
Jeanette, Huddersfield
It will put on a concert that the well heeled will attend for free. Some already wealthy performers will massage their own egos and feel that they are right on. Not one person in Africa will notice a change.
Gerry, UK
It is an admirable effort by Bob Geldof to try and help, certainly. And, of course, one should always help where one can. However, asking the G8 nations to cancel debt is, in my opinion, not the way to go. Take the US for example: The public health system is appalling and needs to be overhauled. Actually, that's also the case for the UK. Additionally, there is, although to a far lesser extent, poverty within the G8 countries themselves. Maybe it would be more sensible to sort our own problems out first before taking on other countries' problems? It still is good to see that some of today's pop stars are trying to make a difference, albeit it does have a hint of image boosting to it. Either way, I hope that something useful will come out at the end of it all.
Peter, London, UK
Capitalism needs poverty. A cheap migrant workforce maintains the West's comfortable lifestyle and consumer desire for inexpensive goods. Nothing will change until we find a more humane way of living. But I shall still take my protest to the G8 summit because change has to start somewhere.
Philip Smith, Kingsbridge, Devon
I am definitely going to try and get a ticket; I mean, all these great acts in one place! However, I don't actually think that anyone is going to take any notice. Poverty in Africa will never end while their corrupt governments are massacring and robbing their people.
Christine Hawkins, Manchester, England
Unfortunately, all Live 8 will achieve is two things. Firstly: The money raised will feed the starving millions for a few more days and prolong their inevitable and ultimate demise, and hence their misery. Secondly: It will sooth the consciences of the donors and performers, and delude them into thinking that they have achieved something to help. In truth only governments have the means to do anything and they prefer not to, or they would be doing something by now. I'm sorry to be so cynical, but the hard truth is that the world simply doesn't care...not enough anyway. It's nice that ordinary folk do.
Graham Geer, Gladstone, Australia
Live 8 will achieve none of the objectives that it sets out to achieve. We have, over many years, provided charitable funds to alleviate suffering in the Third World. In my 50 years of taking stock of what takes place, especially in the African continent I have observed no significant change to the level of suffering. Decade upon decade the system worsens. We now read about "ethnic cleansing" as if it was part of the natural order of events in these despotic regions. What good will throwing more money at the problem achieve? It will serve only to bolster the despotic leaders of these states and finance their further atrocities towards their own people. We richer nations of the Western world seem to need the Geldofs in order to salve our consciences for being fortunate enough to live in a better world. Tackle the root of the problem, not the effect of the problem!
Mike Nye, Slough, UK
Let's face it. This is really just a chance for bands to get even more exposure. If people really think this will help the poor... well they're deluded.
Arion, Albania
What will Live 8 achieve? Nothing. How about raising awareness of the corruption, bad governments, genocide and lack of Aids awareness that Africa really stands for?
Tim Lawrence, Swindon, Wilts
I agree with the principles of Live 8 but what on earth is this Long Walk all about? Again, the principles are sound but all that is going to happen is the dumb anti-capitalist hooligans will hijack it and turn the whole thing into a riot. The last big "demonstration" that lot put on in London resulted in war memorials being defaced and vandalised. Well done Bob for encouraging mindlessness.
John, Sheffield, UK
I believe this effort is a drop in the sea when you look at the immense challenges in Africa. One world concert, on one day, is not going to change anything. What has happened since Live-Aid with hunger? People are still dying of hunger today. I think the purpose, in principle, is great. But the hill is so steep that the top is unreachable. One day won't change the trend. If they want to make an impact, do this every year! That will put consistent pressure on world leaders to do something about it. Create momentum.
Brian Friel, San Diego, CA
Nothing. It will not improve the trade balance nor unemployment in poor countries. It will not bolster the value of their currencies. It will not protect their nascent industries.
Dr Yousef Abdulla, Orpington UK
Nothing. Until Africa takes responsibility for itself, stops blaming the West for all its troubles and takes steps to improve the lives of its own people, nothing - but absolutely nothing the West does will help in the long run.
Christopher W Whybrow, Baguio City, Philippines
Whether Live 8 is an effort to raise money or awareness, it didn't work last time so why should it work now? Many Africans still live in dreadful conditions.
Andy, Edinburgh, Scotland
Corrupt African elites put their money into British, Swiss and other European off-shore accounts. Let's prove we're serious about reducing poverty, returning stolen money and creating stable democracies, by arresting one or two bankers. That would have rather more effect than warbling pop-singers.
Eric Northey, Stockport, UK
If Bob Geldof is successful in getting one million people to march on Edinburgh I doubt if this would be peaceful and could lead to mob rule on an unprecedented scale. You will find all sorts of factions, some of which would not care a jot about Africa that would spoil his party and lead to mass arrests by the police, and where would we put them all? I am tempted to say a remote Scottish Island if one exists. Would it not be better to take this army of protestors to Africa and overthrow the cruel and wicked regimes that exist there and the world would be much happier as a consequence.
Roger Mereweather, Sandown, IOW, UK
| SUGGEST A DEBATE This topic was suggested by John Kent, UK:
Will Live 8 be a success like the original Live Aid? |
Edinburgh citizens are encouraged to open doors to marchers next month. Fair enough Bob and Midge, following a soda pop at your place to keep the spirits up!
George Rowan, Leeds
Nothing, except a great day out for rock fans. Africa is beyond redemption. For twenty years we have been throwing money at it and for what. More massacres, more wars, more corrupt leaders, more people infected by Aids, more starving children...
John, France
People seem to have missed the point of this event, it is not to raise cash for Africa, it's to shame our politicians into doing what they have been talking about for the last 20 years or more. End Third world debt. We will never get it paid back anyway so why keep racking up the interest. Cancel the debts to countries with sensible leadership and get the chuckle brothers (I think we all know who I mean) to invade all the others and implement a regime change.
Danny, UK
| The concerts should come at the end of the battle against poverty, not at the beginning |
We will drive our cars to the show, hoist our Burberry umbrellas skyward when it starts to rain, and chug an ice cold Coke to slake a thirst borne of so much making a difference. The truth is, we feel we deserve entertainment as reward for doing the right thing. The concerts should come at the end of the battle against poverty, not at the beginning.
K, Nottingham
Quite frankly, the likes of Bob Geldof and Elton John are naive in the extreme. They live cocooned in luxury devoid of reality. May I suggest that their conscience stems from the contradiction between their lifestyles and those of everyone else? The UK contribution to reducing poverty is immense. These self-styled luvvies and latter day saviours have nothing useful to say.
Franklin, Johnstone, Scotland
| Thank God we still have some idealists who don't just leave it at the spoken word |
Reading the remarks made so far on this website is reason enough to applaud Bob Geldof and Co. for finding the motivation, time, energy and will to once again at least try to make a difference in our spoilt, cynical world. Those who condemn rich pop stars for holding onto their fortunes are, I suspect, unwilling to part with a cent of their own dosh. How easy it is to criticise and do nothing. Well done Bob, thank God we still have some idealists who don't just leave it at the spoken word.
Gerie van Lil, Amsterdam, Holland
For once I have actually been impressed by Geldof. He compared the current global system to "a racket that Capone would be proud of". At last he is speaking some truth. Go Bob!
Joon Flowers, Middlesex, UK
For those calling for pop stars to give some of their fortunes to the cause I think you are rather missing the point. Third world debt is billions upon billions. Bono donating �50m, or whatever, would be a drop in the ocean, the same as you or I or anyone else donating whatever we could afford. If money was drip fed into nations it would disappear amongst the bureaucracy. Plus, who would decide which nations were to benefit first? The only way forward is to cancel Third world debt, but this should not be done until solid structures are in place to tackle famine, disease and civil war.
Jamie, Staffordshire
Millions of my forefathers died when transported to the West. They did not require a passport or a visa to come to the West, neither were they called economic migrants. The world remembers the holocaust but not these Africans. The western world is built on the sweat of the African and the ingenuity of the white man. It is only fair that the descendants of both should benefit from the wealth so generated.
Femi Ade, London, UK
Band Aid was a great name for it - because it was a band aid solution to a gaping wound of a problem. And this time around will be no different. Foreign debt is not Africa's main problem; neither are poverty or trade restrictions. Africa's main problem is and always has been Africa. African ideals, African ethics, African culture and African society. Until they take steps to resolve these issues there will never be progress.
Iain Howe, Amsterdam, Netherlands
So Edinburgh gets the march and London gets the concert, typical London bias. The G8 meeting will be in Scotland Mr Geldof, we too have venues where you can hold your concert.
Dene Brown, Edinburgh, UK
They have achieved little yet other than making the cause known. But let's hope they make the G8 summit sit up and look beyond protecting their own interests of growth and profit at least just for once although they will actually do nothing to help the situation just talk about it?
Tom, Glasgow
| It does irritate me that this is all about European and US musicians telling us about Africa |
While I commend Bob Geldof's efforts it does irritate me that this is all about European and US musicians telling us about Africa. Why not showcase African musicians as well - e.g. Salif Keita, Youssou N'Dour, Cesaria Evora, Miriam Makeba - many of whom outclass and outsell our pop and rock stars. This would be a clear signal that we do not need to sing to raise awareness for Africa but that, given the means, Africa can sing for itself (and do it very well) and that they have invited other musicians from around the world to join them in solidarity.
Liz Howell, London, UK The poverty that is criminally imposed on Africa by the leaders of countries such as the US and the UK reminds me of a slogan sent to me by an American friend recently: "Never have so few taken so much from so many for so long". The time is coming when this will change however.
MX, London, UK
The bad attitudes are ridiculous; surely some sort of aid/campaign to raise awareness is better than the current attitude of changing the channel/turning our heads away when we see something we don't like? Fair play to a group who have no reason to pay attention and who could live in a protected bubble like a lot of celebs for using the fame for something other than seats in the Ivy!
Niamh Regan, Ireland
I'm sure Bob Geldof's heart's in the right place, but being on an idealistic ego trip is no excuse for ignoring the facts. He rants on as if it's us in the West who are responsible for the suffering of these poor people in Africa. Surely it's the endemic corruption in the oppressive regimes that is the main cause of this misery.
Hilton Teper, St Albans, UK
I think the Live 8 concert is a brilliant idea to raise money and awareness of global poverty. However the same cannot be said for Bob Geldof's plans to have a million people enter Edinburgh. I think the most people that have ever converged in the centre of Edinburgh is 150,000, and the mere idea of any more than that is ridiculous and incredibly irresponsible.
Lucy, Glasgow
Coldplay failed to save the UK from the crazy frog. What makes them think they can save an entire continent?
Richard, UK
I saw the first Live Aid concert on TV. Good cause, and the best entertainment I ever saw. It's about time Mr Geldof!
Linda, Claymont, Delaware
If all rich countries gave 5% of the annual budget allocated to defence spending for the next 20 years, poverty problems in Third world countries would be over very quickly. Instead, the efforts of Bob Geldof are bringing hope to millions of people who need help and at least he cares enough to do something about what is happening.
EC, USA
Why Edinburgh? Why not where the G8 is being held? In fact Bob, why don't you do it outside your house? I will, along with many others I am sure, sue Mr Geldof if any of my property is damaged. Blair, Bush and all the other leaders at the G8 summit will not bat an eyelid at any demo 50 miles down the road. After all, they are perfectly safe behind their wire fences and scores of police. It's my home town that's going to get wrecked!
Mike, Edinburgh
| Events like this will raise the profile of the cause |
I think it's a brilliant idea and I'm desperate to go! Events like this will raise the profile of the cause and will hopefully make more people stop and think about the situation in Africa, and what they themselves can do to help.
Naomi, Warwick, England You are the leader of a small African state which suddenly has a multi-million dollar windfall from debt relief.
Do you:
Open a Swiss bank account?
Upgrade your arsenal and attack your neighbouring countries? Build palaces for your relations?
Or... feed your starving population?
I think Geldof and his disciples should march on Harare and Addis Ababa, not Edinburgh and Auchterarder.
Bryan, Edinburgh
I was horrified to read the recent comments regarding the apparent lack of so-called ethnic minority performers in the cast of Live 8, including the use of the word "hideous". The only thing that's hideous is that the misguided individuals making these comments are unable to put their sad attitudes to one side and support the efforts of Bob Geldof and his team to help their ethnic brothers and sisters in Africa.
Alan, Holmes Chapel, Cheshire, England
I'm sure it's a good cause, but pressuring world leaders in to doing things that they simply don't have the time or indeed the power to do is unrealistic, and Mr Geldof should know better. He should also mind his language, I'm appalled by how much he swears.
Ben, London
It is reported that George Bush's plan for space dominance will cost about 50 billion dollars. Would that be enough?
Robert, Birstall, UK
It's funny how these B list celebrities/musicians suddenly want to propel themselves into the limelight... and it's not party time, these are serious world issues. While the intention appears good there are too many egos involved for it to be anything short of a catwalk for these people to parade themselves and polish their own halos.
DM, London
I'd love to hear from Mbeki and Mugabe on this issue - I think we all know what they would say - and that is the problem in a nutshell Bob.
GB, Hong Kong
| Bob Geldof has certainly proved he has rather more will to pursue a cause long-term than most politicians |
Bob Geldof has certainly proved he has rather more will to pursue a cause long-term than most politicians. Band Aid and Live Aid were successful in achieving short-term disaster relief, but of course did not tackle the underlying causes. Only the politicians can do that and they only seem to respond if they feel the pressure from their electorates. These will be prominent events in the worlds' media and Geldof has shown his genuine commitment to this cause over more than 20 years, so I think people will respond to the cry and hopefully galvanise our great leaders into action rather than rhetoric.
Bruce Acton, Winchester, UK
All these people harping on about these mega-rich rock stars giving half their money need to take note that these stars donate time, money, ideas, raise awareness, entertain, host charity events and still half of all their money would not fix the problem. They are trying to get the governments of the world to take note of the situation and I think it's a shame that it comes down to Bono and Bob Geldof and the rest of them to have to show the leaders the situation. Good luck to all the entertainers who are trying to make a change in the world that we all live in.
Jason U, Englishman in LA
Hey, it's a big complex problem with lots of causes, and it will be difficult to do anything to help. So let's not even bother trying, and while we're at it, let's take cheap shots at a bunch of rich old rock stars who are trying to do something. It makes me proud to be English!
John, England
| Unless the power of business is curtailed, the business of power will be corrupt |
Big business in the developed world is responsible for Africa's plight. African leaders are corrupt because they are allowed to be. How many commissions are paid to African leaders and their families when we agree to trade with their regimes? The ECG are underwritten by UK taxpayers, meaning that if (for example) British Aerospace get ripped off by a corrupt regime, we cover the losses! If we didn't sell weapons to these regimes, or try to install our own friendly corrupt regimes through bloody coups (Mark Thatcher et al), then maybe Africa might stand a chance. I think that unless the power of business is curtailed, the business of power will be corrupt.
Johnny, London, UK
Okay, Africa is the responsible for its own development and the difficulties from that, but what about the exploratory colonization made in those lands that according to the Eurocentric historic-economical context of the world meant to be civilized. Whatsoever, half-light and yet a backyard territory from rich countries, Africa needs to learn how to fish without being victim or guilty, let's get rid of the foreign debts that kill Africa.
Airon, Feira de Santana, Brazil
In attempting to solve one problem Bob Geldof creates many others. He wants a million people to attend the Edinburgh Live 8 Concert. How much air pollution, CO2 emissions, road congestion, police and other support costs will this create? We can support the anti-poverty campaign, but it might be better to think Green, stay at home, and give the money we save to those in need.
Valerie, Aylesbury
In order for Live 8 to have an impact the corruption in Africa must be eradicated, starting with the various rulers who are oppressing their own people, until that happens nothing will change, democracy and justice is what the people of Africa need and hopefully the music will be the vehicle to carry the message. Rock on Bob
Mike Poland, Macduff, Aberdeenshire
The problem is not just raising money to help the needy. It is ensuring that it goes where it is needed. Too much of this money is siphoned off by corrupt politicians and other people in high office for their own personal gain. Until an agency has control of it to stop this happening, the situation won't be changed.
Tony D, Wakefield
What people are being asked to do here is make a statement. Represent yourselves and your families. Stand up and say the poverty that people, especially innocent children, are exposed to is not acceptable. We should not argue that it won't do any good or suggest that there is no point. In democratic countries political leaders are there to represent the people not themselves and we must make them understand this. You can make a difference. What happens over the next few months could affect generations to come. One day poverty could come knocking at your door. We must do this if humanity is to have any sort of decent future.
Clare, Newcastle, UK
At least the penny has dropped that it does no good just raising money and sending aid as so little ends up doing permanent good. But raising awareness and writing off debt will also fail to have any long term impact unless corrupt regimes are taken out of the equation, and control put in the hands of reputable organisations - even the people themselves. Otherwise these nations will be right back to square one within a decade. After all, it takes me very little time to put a balance on my credit card again after I've cleared it.
Richard Baylis, Chelmsford, Essex
| Cancelling debt for some African countries is unfair on others who endeavour to pay it off |
Nice idea but not sure what it will actually achieve apart from creating a memorable spectacle. Also, cancelling debt for some African countries is unfair on others who endeavour to pay it off. Cancelling debt will also make lenders more shy in lending money in the future, consequence of which will be higher borrowing rates.
James, London I was only 7 when the first Live Aid happened, but it was the first time I realised that the world isn't a level playing field. If Live 8 can help inform another young generation, let alone drive some to action, then it will have achieved something. Corruption will only continue without awareness.
Paul D, Bristol, UK
This will achieve nothing but more self righteous posturing by a bunch of uninformed pop starts. Here is a suggestion from an African, don't bunk off work and go to Edinburgh, take your wages from that week or day and invest in African companies or stock exchanges. We are not fools, beggars or perpetual victims and are subject to exactly the same economic rules as everyone else. Bypass our corrupt governments and your self-serving politicians and celebrities and invest in individual African companies. Go on, do something truly radical
Nkita, London, UK
Of course it will achieve something! People power is very important; it's what keeps people like Messrs Bush and Blair in a (reasonable amount) of check. If enough people show their support for something as worthy as trying to tackle poverty in the world, then only good things can result. The development of African nations has been crippled by their "friends" in the developed world lending them money at indulgent interest rates. Mr Bush would also do well to remember that poverty is an important ingredient in breeding terrorism. If poverty were eliminated, the "war on terror" would be won.
Simon, Southampton
Who cares how much money Bob Geldof or any of the other artists have. This isn't a repeat of Live Aid and they're not looking for donations or raising funds. It's to raise people's awareness that there are ways other than charity to help combat poverty. It's already helping in that there is a worldwide dialogue and the event is a month away.
Kelly, Boston, USA
I think Sir Bob Geldof is an amazing person. He doesn't just sing and spend, but really rallies people. WE can now do something to feel as though we are helping instead of feeling frustrated. I wish him and the project all the luck in the world!
Rebecca, Wakefield, England
| Randomly throwing money at this gigantic problem is never going to make it go away |
Randomly throwing money at this gigantic problem is never going to make it go away. What we need to do is address the shortcomings in infrastructure, in education, in science and technology and basic know-how so the Third World can finally stand on its own 2 feet. Helping end civil war and removing corrupt regimes would also be nice. But who's going to take on those responsibilities? I'm not sure how fair it is to ask ordinary taxpayers to contribute time and time again while the Elton Johns and the Bill Gates and the Oprahs and the Donald Trumps of the world continue to sit on an inconceivable fortune and live in obscene opulence. Bob Geldof makes more in a week than I do in a year - for him to preach to me about giving is nothing short of laughable!
N, UK (currently in US) I commend Bob Geldof for his determination and ideology, but I hope that he has learned from his previous forays into Ethiopia that the best intentions can sometimes have dire consequences. Debts need to be cancelled and money needs to be given, but equal portions of democratic accountability for African leaders and Western banks need to be administered too. I hope Bob Geldof has the sense to campaign for more than just money.
Hayden Eastwood, Edinburgh, UK
Live 8 is the best opportunity to effect change that we have had for years. I am so tired of supporting good causes that get ignored by politicians. Geldof is one man who can actually influence politics - he and the whole of Africa need the support of people across the world. Actual and visible support - not just words. Political pressure is the only way to change systems and we can make this happen.
Flora Ellis, Cirencester
Very little. Increased traffic congestion, additional policing cost and misery for all the inhabitants for those cities concerned. Why? Aid is not the answer. Political reform and economic stability is what deprived African countries need. Africa should be trading and manufacturing its way out of poverty in the same way China is doing. Supporting democratic, non-corrupt government should be the focus of people's efforts, not another pop concert.
Will, Manchester
What Bob should do is perform in Africa and organise marches to the governments in Africa who run the corrupt regimes that result in all of these problems. I applaud him for doing what he is doing (and for everything he has done in the past) but surely the people we now need to make a point to are those who are actually making the problem.
Khalid, Birmingham
Live Aid/8, is very effective at raising awareness and keeping Africa in the minds of the Western world. However, as far as direct help goes, the last thing Africa needs is more money thrown at it. The problems of African poverty lie in deep political corruption and trade injustice on a global scale. Live 8 is definitely a good thing, but it's no solution.
Will Bugler, Manchester, UK Saddened to hear the 'establishment' come out against children taking time off school to attend the Live 8 rally. What better reason than this to miss school. The future of Africa and, for that matter, the rest of us, is much more important than a few classes. Only when everyone stands up to be counted will we be able to make a difference and be listen to.
Michael, York
This concert is about raising awareness and giving the world leaders a reminder that we want change. Yes some of the performers are rich but they are willing to give of their time, money and reputation. If we don't get up and shout at our leaders they won't feel it's important to deal with Africa's poor governance, corruption, debt, unfair trade and AIDS problems (to name a few). If you feel that you've got a hard enough life coping with your mortgage, etc. Think what it would be like if you were born in Africa and trying to cope on $2 dollars a day. I hope and pray this will be bigger and more successful than the Live 8 and Make Poverty History Campaign ever dreamed of.
Judith, Guildford, Surrey
I truly and deeply hope it succeeds. Getting the G8 to do this would be the single most important act that politicians could undertake at this time. I just wish their sense of shame was as well developed as in the rest of us!
Mark Cain, Leicester
I wish everyone the best with the event, I was only 10 when the first live aid took place, but I remember the atmosphere being electric, shame Queen have not been included in the list for old times sake given they are on tour currently it may be difficult.
John, York
Geldof is doing more than I am, so I will not criticize his efforts. I hope people use their awareness of the poverty problem to put pressure on their local MPs, who will, in turn, I hope put pressure on the government to stop them contributing to and ignoring corruption. Also, I hope that individuals have some awareness of where the products come from that they buy. I urge people to use their spending power by not supporting exploitative organisations. There is plenty of money in this world and there are plenty of resources. The problem of poverty is political and I believe a revolution is needed.
Katharine Friedmann, Leicester, UK Brilliant idea, but I wonder how much these stars give to poverty each year? If their so "feed the world" why don't they give half there earnings towards the campaigns, give up there posh cars and big houses? Is this not just an excuse for us at home to get a good concert and for some music artists to sell a few more records and make themselves look good?
Richard, Cambridge
It will, of course, achieve nothing - well not for Africans anyway. The two greatest problems facing Africa, so great they dwarf every other consideration, are war and corrupt government. Africa isn't short of natural resources, talented people or enough temperate landmass to feed all its people. It is short of peace and legitimate democratic accountability. And the only people who can do anything about that are Africans themselves - not Bob and Bono.
Bill Martin, Barnsley, UK
Who does Bob Geldof think he is in relation to asking people to turn up at Edinburgh? Is he going to be held responsible when the usual street battles and property damage at these G8 events occur? I hope Edinburgh City Council will consider taking him to civil court if there are problems as I only see his remarks as inflammatory.
Andy Haldane, Kirkcaldy, Scotland
Bunk off, what! I would say give the children two days off so they can do their bit for Live 8, after all the awareness is education. The teachers could also do their bit. Come on, wake up do not try to make it a bad thing. Well done Sir Bob Geldof, and good luck in your mission to try to stop world poverty.
Doreen Renphrey, Poole, Dorset
It will raise awareness, and that has to be a good thing. Small ripples make big waves, as they say.
Carl J, Oxford
I think something on this scale had to be done. A number of the world leaders don't seem to have poverty issues at the top of their agenda. This will enable them to see that even if they don't care too much about it, their citizens do. I think it is people like Messrs Geldof and Ure who make a difference in the world.
Rob Morris, UK
| Africa holds the major responsibility in getting itself out of poverty |
As a person of African origin, I am happy that Bob Geldof is trying to raise awareness about the plight of the people of Africa but as much as there are a number of policies made by the West that have aggravated African poverty, there is an even deeper problem that needs to be tackled first before any of the aims of Live 8 can be really effective. It seems that all the blame is being put on the West's doorsteps and yet Africa holds the major responsibility in getting itself out of poverty.
Yes, it would be great to cancel world debt and increase aid but there is no use doing all this if the money never reaches those people that actually need it but ends up in the hands of a very select few. There needs to be a change in the culture of corruption that African leaders have for the effort of the Live 8 campaign to make a significant impact. Without this, I fear that though we will have a great Live 8 concert watched by many, the people in Africa who are in poverty will be no better off than they were before the concert.
Ede, London
Whilst raising awareness is always a good thing, if it hasn't worked the first time, why will it work the second time? Instead of giving more handouts to corrupt regimes who just take the money for themselves, why not go to war like we did in Iraq? Change the governments and the problem will be eradicated, easier said than done I know but it would make a change to fight the cause instead of being reactionary as is always the way with us in England.
Dean, Leeds, UK
I am a singer in a band and we played a mini festival against poverty in Africa last year. We wanted to collect money for a generator to pump water to a village who had until then no running water. It came as a shock when we later discovered that the tribal chief bought two Mercedes Benz limousines for his personal use with the money.
Karola, Germany
A well-intentioned but simplistic initiative. Fair trade and a zero tolerance approach to corruption and bad governance in Africa would do more good than simply cancelling debt. Where has all the aid given before gone? Look at Nigeria which is poorer despite being one of the world's major oil exporting countries? Good intentions abound but the problems of Africa will not be solved by simplistic solutions.
Carmelo, Brighton, UK
I think it is a shame that Bob Geldof has told people to go to a rally in Edinburgh on 6 July. That is only four days after the rally which has been organised by a whole host of other people for months. This may mean that the Make Poverty History Campaign rally is poorly attended. I am very disappointed in both Bob and Midge for announcing another rally. They should have put the concerts on another date and told people to go to Edinburgh or hold their own rally in their local city.
Gillian Potter-Merrigan, Urmston, Manchester
| I hope that Bob Geldof doesn't read this, or he might wish he hadn't bothered |
I am staggered by the number of uncharitable comments here. It makes me sad to think this is a balanced opinion. I hope that none of those people get tickets. I hope that Bob Geldof doesn't read this, or he might wish he hadn't bothered. No single individual can make a difference. Neither me with my expensive car, or Bob with his spare cash.
As a community, we can ease the suffering to some, as proven by Live Aid, the Tsunami relief fund, and everything in between. But the point of Live 8 is to shout that the only way to make a difference on a global scale is through political change. It won't solve the all the problems in one sweep, but it will stop the downward spiral and allow countries in poverty to help themselves.
James Latham, Bristol
Let's see now. If all these mega-rich pop stars gave half their fortunes to Africa the problem would be solved. But I don't think that's ever likely to happen...do you?
Graham Neat, Romford, UK
Over the years it has really only been Irish, British, Canadian and other Commonwealth musicians that have stepped up to the plate on issues with Africa. Where have big named US bands been on this issue? Is it we are more socially conscious? I'm not sure but it would help if US bands got more involved besides just the Live Aid concerts.
John, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Maybe they should be looking at the real causes of poverty in Africa: continual mismanagement and corrupt leadership throughout the continent. Cancelling the debt will give Africa a breathing space, but will not solve the root causes of poverty, Aids and hunger.
Omri Stephenson, London, UK
Raising awareness about problems of poverty in Africa can never be a bad thing. Bob Geldof et al are great and I will be looking forward to the concert in Hyde Park. The reality though is that the solution to African problems lies in Africa, not anywhere else! Cancelling debt, increasing aid, and fair trade rules for Africa can be compared to the role of a midwife. You must carry the pregnancy yourself! Governance issues, inclusive practices and the crisis of the state in Africa must be tackled first before anything else can have meaning.
Robert Byaruhanga, Liverpool, UK
| It's time to raise the awareness of a new generation |
I was 12 when the 1st Live Aid concerts took place and can still recall the electric atmosphere generated - and that was just watching it on TV. Images of what was happening in Africa were burnt onto my consciousness. Today, I and many of my peers try to get involved in campaigning for change in Africa, whether through political action or simply by wearing the white band of Make Poverty History or buying Fair Trade goods. I seriously doubt if that would be the case if the images of Live Aid and Band Aid had not affected us so deeply. It's time to raise the awareness of a new generation, so that Africa is not forgotten and people realise that it's not all futile - even the smallest contribution can help.
Emily, Berlin (ex UK) I wish the team well. I shall be watching the July concerts on the very same TV that I watched the first Live Aid in 1985 (yes it's survived 20 years). It's still going strong, as is the desire to once and for all get rid of poverty, disease, and exploitation in the world.
Gerry Budd, Chester England
I am hoping that they will invite some of the top African artists to appear at each of these concerts. They are as talented as anyone else.
Mari-Ann, London, Canada
There seems to be a misunderstanding that this is about giving money - it's not. It's about cancelling the enormous debts that developing world countries have to pay huge amounts of interest on. More than half of the aid that we give comes straight back to Western banks in the form of interest payments. If the developed world cancelled the debt, the developing world could move forward and actually pay its own way. Freeing people to be able to afford to support themselves is the way forward.
Gav Wilson, Oxford
Despite the good intentions and efforts of musicians such as Geldof, the problems of Africa, or for that matter of any other developing country or region, will not be solved by rising aid, that is paternalistic and pitiful. What Africa really needs is the developed world to cease using double standards as its currency. Geldof and Bono are not tackling the root of the poverty problem and that's why they can shake hands with Blair and other G8 leaders.
Alfonso, Luxembourg
What we Africans, need is not aid (that always comes with terms and conditions), we want fair trade. If your governments can let us sell our products to you, that will help relieve poverty.
Tsitso, Stevenage
Well, from reading everyone's comments, we have a pretty mixed feedback, mainly positive. I would say anything that can bring attention to the grave poverty in Africa is worth the attention as long as it accomplishes what it initially set out to do. Hat's off to you Sir Bob Geldof, make the difference!!!
Yogini, Plano, TX, USA
Could they have picked more boring and predicable line up? Elton John campaigning against poverty! It that some kind of joke, the man spends �100,000 a year on flowers! For all of Geldof's high intentions this is just another opportunity for millionaire rock stars to massage their egos and quell their consciences. Like the previous concert in the end it will change nothing.
Craig, London (ex New Zealand)
| If anyone wants to do something to Make Poverty History in a practical way, then make the effort to buy Fair trade products |
If anyone wants to do something to Make Poverty History in a practical way, then make the effort to buy Fair trade products. It's a great idea to have this concert to raise awareness and put pressure on global politicians, but everyone should realise that as consumers they have the greatest power to make a difference in the long term by making definitive purchasing choices which will support small co-operatives and trading units in developing countries.
If everyone who buys a coffee, chocolate, sugar and tea on his/her way to work or school tomorrow, were to buy Fair trade (rather than their usual brand) it would start to make a difference to so many people now in poverty.
Rachel, London, UK
I wonder how much the free tickets will change hands for on eBay.
Luke, London
I was at the original Live Aid concert on 13 July 1985 at Wembley Stadium. It was a day never to be forgotten.
Paul Smith, Guildford, England
| Raising money is always good but it's never going to be good enough |
Raising money is always good but it's never going to be good enough. This concert is a fantastic idea, it gives the world a great chance to stand together and make the world's leaders listen and understand why this is all so important!
Sarah Walker, Birkenhead, England
I don't think lack of awareness has anything to do with this problem's continued presence in world affairs. Everyone knows what the solution is; including the USA, which continues to drag its feet and find new excuses for not cancelling debt. A better move might be to somehow prevent the caterers from getting into the G8 summit - let the world's leaders find out what going hungry feels like.
David Hazel, Fareham, UK
I think this can only be positive. Anything that keeps the plight of Africa and other poverty stricken countries in the public arena has got to be beneficial. The impact of an event like this can't be underestimated. Bob will organise� the leaders must listen!
Becky, Shropshire, UK
Surely anything that helps raise awareness of the tragedy that is Africa must help. It's not about money or aid it is about a change of political will. It can be done! It must be done now. If the G8 do not act on the proposals to help Africa then they are not welcome in my country!
Rick Allardice, Alloa, Scotland
I think it's a good idea, but why have it on the same day as the huge Make Poverty History walk in Edinburgh?
Kate, Edinburgh
It is a positive movement compared to the typical G8 riots. Associating positive feelings with a difficult cause is a noble endeavour. Good luck.
Brian Corcoran, Swords, Ireland
I am only 16 but I have been told about the amazing events of Live Aid in 1985 by my mother and I only wish I had been there to contribute! The state of Africa then, and now, is utterly crazy, when so many countries could quite easily change things in a second! However the people who are in charge of these decisions are people who really do not care. I am very pleased that Bob Geldof is around to take a stand against politicians, and to try and make a difference in the world.
Tassia Butlin, Alton, Hampshire
Never mind the Spice Girls reforming - how about Take That reforming for a one-off gig at Live 8?
John Lamb, London, UK
As a 35-year-old American with two small children I am very upset that this America bashing is going to come back to my city. It is very easy for the super rich rock stars to tell me what should be done with my tax dollars. I work 10 hours a day to feed my family, not Africa. Dave Mathews was just on the radio about the Philly show asking what we have done for Africa. How about the hospitals, vaccinations, schools, roads, computers and internet, food etc that the USA sends and builds? How come we never get any credit for that?
Chris Salinas, Philadelphia, PA, USA
To Chris Salinas, Philadladelphia: And who do you think grows your food? How long do you think they work and can the feed their families? Answers 1. Those in poverty 2. Every available hour 3. No they can't Maybe people are America bashing for a reason.
Mark Briggs, Godalming, England
This is a fantastic initiative to raise profile and finance for Make Poverty History. I am in complete disagreement with Chris from Philadelphia, however. We are the richest nations in the world - just the spare change in our pockets makes a difference. It's a change of heart we all need, not just a change of mind. If the tables were turned and we were in the same situation as those in Africa, we'd be crying out for help. It's such a massive need and everyone can make a difference. It may just be a drop in the ocean, but the ocean is made of many drops!
Ali Quinney, Ealing, London
No. I think Bob Geldof is a saint, but misguided. Live Aid proved that if a country can't feed a thousand people today, it can't feed three thousand tomorrow.
Ian
I really don't think it will make any difference whatsoever - did a million people protesting about the Iraq war change any minds?
Susan, Bangor, County Down
I'm sorry, but throwing money at endless problems won't solve it - political pressure is what's needed and the guts to tackle those dictators that will revel in even more do-gooders sending them money for nothing (and even chips for free!)
Tony Humphreys, Prestatyn, UK
I was 14 when Live Aid was on and donated my pocket money to help. I wont donate anything this time because it's nothing more than a political racket!
Craig, Sheffield
I will be desperate to go. Firstly what a way to demonstrate to the G8 countries how we feel about poverty. Secondly, what a way to be a part of history and to see such wonderful acts all at the same time! Where do I get my ticket?
Louise Rigdon, Swansea, UK
Why can't we see more of things like this around the world? People should be helping each other and helping the world. Not blowing each other up!
Debbie, Edinburgh, Scotland
Anyone who owns a house can sell it, move into rented accommodation and use the money to actually save lives. Unfortunately in reality, what brand of car we drive is more important to us than saving lives in Africa. This concert will be another opportunity for caring people to feel as if they're doing something before going back to a life of unbridled consumption. I'd like to know what Bob Geldof's bank balance is.
Christian Tiburtius, Reading, UK
One-Minute World News 
News services
E-mail this to a friend 
Printable version 
Images from Live 8
