The US National Guard has been assigned to protect Sunday's Oscars ceremony amid uncertainty over whether the event should go ahead. Around 2,000 peace campaigners will be given space outside Hollywood's Kodak Theatre to voice their public opposition to the war in Iraq.
Celebrities at this year's event will not be interviewed or pose for photographs on the red carpet as part of a toned-down ceremony.
Organisers are planning a more sober event this Sunday and there will be no seating for fans outside the theatre.
Does it seem inappropriate to hold the Oscars at a time of war? Should it be cancelled altogether? Or will you welcome it as a diversion from current events?
Thank you for your e-mails. This debate is now closed. A selection of your comments is published below.
Of course it should be cancelled. Otherwise the Islamic world which already thinks that west does not give a damn for its suffering will feel further alienated. I find it totally disgusting and appalling to see people having fun when Baghdad is being bombed and the military campaign is being broadcast live like a computer game.
Sel�uk G�lta, Turkey
Go ahead but please don't bash the government. These men are laying their lives on the line for our freedom. I believe the Oscars should continue - this is what the troops are fighting for, our way of life.
Ian, USA
 The celebrities who make these anti-war statements and then scatter for Beverly Hills or mansions in European capitals appear to just be doing the vogue thing  |
I don't watch the Oscars but what really bothers me is the way the people get sucked in by these vocal actors in Europe and the US. The celebrities who make these anti-war statements and then scatter for Beverly Hills or mansions in European capitals appear to just be doing the vogue thing. The brave road to take is to support our troops who had to leave family behind and fight a cause that will bring freedom to the Iraqi people and hope to humankind.
Jane Rubino, USA I believe that even though there is a war in Iraq at the moment we should not stop everything and become completely focused on the war. It will always be on our minds but the whole country cannot come to a standstill.
Penny Andrews, England
Too much fuss is given to the Oscars. However, it is still a powerful media event and so the ceremony should take place and should be done in a very sombre tone with focus on the world-shaking events occurring right now.
Alan Hesse, Bolivia
People are dying and they want to have their stupid celebration? |
Absolutely not! How dare they? Hypocrites. After all, shouldn't they show some respect for the fighting men and women and cancel their grotesque display of pomposity and disgusting glamour. People are dying and they want to have their stupid celebration? It is wrong, remember many of these overpaid no-talents stared in many war movies and now they have the nerve to protest the war.
Iain Black, Good old USofA The fact that the Academy Awards are going ahead as planned and not being postponed merely serves to underscore how superficially decadent the West has become. Who with a good conscience can watch the stars egoistically preen across the red carpet and give acceptance speeches laced with false emotions as innocent blood is being spilled in Iraq?
Christopher McGreger, US via Germany
Yes, the Oscars should go on. I also believe that Col. Ollie North should get one for his performance on the CNN for his demonstration on how difficult it is to wear a chemical warfare suit.
P. C. Scott, USA
I've heard that nominees for the Oscars have been forbidden from expressing any anti-war sentiments at the ceremony. If this is true, then certainly the event should be postponed. It sounds like the spirit of McCarthy-ism may be alive and well in tinsel town.
Mark Laurent, New Zealand
Hollywood is a frivolous amusement at best. It is an 'obscenity' for the Oscar to be given as a reward whilst blood is being spilt. Besides which, listening to all the celebs' anti- war speeches leaves me cold. This year I'll pass thank you very much. Celebs should stick to what they do best instead of agitating the public further.
Sin, Australia
I welcome it as a diversion from the current events |
I welcome it as a diversion from the current events, and a salute to the industry for their constant portrayal of the horrors war and the anti-war activist stand. I just saw a Palestinian movie about the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, and it shook me down to the roots.
Naj, USA Of course it should go ahead. What is to be gained by cancelling any events?
Sarah Hamilton, UK
I cannot believe how much credibility the Oscars is given. This event is just an exercise in American back-slapping with the occasional word of praise for the British. To top it all, the most patronising award of all the "Foreign Language" film award. How condescending!
Adam Manktelow, England
I think the Oscars should go, but the organisers should be mindful of the prevailing circumstances. I am quite certain there are hundreds of coalition soldiers in Iraq and elsewhere who are movie buffs just like me. It is only fair they get to know if their favourite actor or actress bags one of the statuettes.
Yaw Owusu, Ghana
I for one love the cinema and the Oscar Awards, but honestly, at the present time people dying in this gruesome war... I am for one certainly not interested in this year's Oscar awards !
Maureen Bueno, France
To go ahead with the Oscars during this time of world crisis is just one more way for US. citizens to show the rest of the world their incredible self-centered and arrogant attitudes. God Bless America
Tonya, Utah USA
No speeches, no fancy dresses, and probably no broadcast of the ceremony |
The Oscars should happen in a simple and quick ceremony. The people who were nominated deserve to be gratified for their work. But it would be ideal if there were no speeches, no fancy dresses, and probably no broadcast of the ceremony.
Juno, UK My personal opinion and that of most the people I've asked feel that holding the Oscar isn't just inappropriate but offensive to most the people here, with war underway and hundreds of people being killed, bombed and having their homes destroyed.
Luma, Syria
Why all the fuss? OK, the Oscar ceremony is one of the highlights of the film industry's calendar, and a lot of money goes into producing it etc - but surely it won't do much harm by postponing it? At least a few weeks?
Suneet, UK
No, no, no - it's obscene that this charade should take place in the overall circumstances
Colin Evans, UK
If the Iraqi people are expected to still carry on going about their business while being bombed then I'm sure the stars will be fine too Michal Zlotkowski, New Zealand |
I don't see why not. People still have to work - be it soldiers or actors. If the Iraqi people are expected to still carry on going about their business while being bombed then I'm sure the stars will be fine too.
Michal Zlotkowski, New Zealand The sad reality of life is that tragedy and death is part and parcel of the daily existence of millions, with or without the war in Iraq. The show has gone on for years in the midst of Aids and wars while brutal regimes have terrorised and inflicted horror on innocents. The only difference is that this time, the world is collectively paying attention to the unfolding tragedy.
Maria, Singapore
It would be disgusting if this ceremony were to go ahead when, on Bush`s instructions, hundreds are being murdered. However, the Americans have little taste so I do not suppose they will want to defer the ceremony.
Garry, UK
Who really cares? Self-indulgent media persons giving each other prizes.
Steve, UK
I think we North Americans are always concerned about our own security more than the security of any other nation and its people. Hence as war is in process, it should be a prime time for us to carry out the celebrating events.
Anton, Toronto/Canada
I think personally we should be more respectful to what's happening in the world in Iraq, if they do go ahead there should be not much of a fuss.
Emma Doyle, Ireland
A low profile celebration is acceptable |
A low profile celebration is acceptable. However, it is distasteful and rather insensitive from Welsh actress Zeta Jones to tap dance and throw a silly show when soldiers and civilians alike are dying in Iraq. She seems to be so self absorbed with her award, it is rather appalling, when other fellow actors and actresses are keeping a low profile.
Shermine, England This is a free country - sure the Oscars should go on. I, for one, am not going to watch and give any more attention to the majority of "stars" who have expressed such derision for our country. Weren't a few of these guys supposed to move out of the country when - their worst fear - President Bush took office? Let them wallow in their wealth and their glamour among themselves. I am glad there will be limited press.
Colleen, USA
People who think actors have some moral high ground or platform from which to speak, don't know much about the entertainment world. It is inappropriate for them to make political commentary in any forum, let alone at the Oscars. Actors like Will Smith and Tom Hanks who have decided not to attend have my respect because they are showing sensitivity to what all people, on both sides of the conflict in Iraq, are going through right now.
Tanya, USA
The Oscars should definitely go on. However I don't feel it should be used as a political platform for the stars to voice their views on the war, after all; it's just an awards ceremony.
Helen, USA
As much as we'd like a diversion from current events, going on with the Oscars seems insensitive. People's lives have been lost, others are in danger right now, and we are going to go on like nothings happening, and wine and dine lavishly on national TV? It would be honourable of the celebrities if they could just bow out this time, and give the respect due to the current serious events of the world right now.
Clara, Cleveland, Ohio, USA
I think the fact that the Oscars are going to be held as if nothing was wrong in the world is appalling |
I think the fact that the Oscars are going to be held as if nothing was wrong in the world is appalling! That the US/UK coalition has just told the whole world to go to hell, does not affect them is a supreme case of total disinterest in everything except themselves. How can one ignore the war and reality?
Uttara SenGupta, India So glad to hear that there will be plenty of room for anti-war protesters at the Oscars. I'm happy the world will see that many people in the USA desire peace and justice, and disagree with governmental policies.
Jill, USA
The Oscars should not be held at the time of war! It's not showing that we care!
Aisha, UK
If it truly were going to be treated as a "welcome diversion" for everyone, it would be ok for the Oscars to go on as planned. However, given the fact they've already made space for anti-war demonstrators but not for fans shows the war would be taking centre stage. It will not be a diversion but will hurt the morale of our troops and the families who have men and women in Iraq risking their lives for the freedoms these celebrities enjoy. I say the Oscars should be postponed and celebrities should stick to what they are paid to do, entertain.
Sandra, Arizona, USA
Yes, the Oscars should go on. In WWII the entertainment didn't stop, so let's not get all wimpy and soft. The show must go on!
Bennie, England
It'd be a good platform for actors and actresses to speak out for or against the war |
Cinema is art. Cinema depicts human emotions and conflicts. Cinema depicts life. Those who think cinema is only for entertainment don't understand cinema, or any art form for that matter. I think the Oscars should be held in a sombre, toned down manner to show respect to those who have died fighting for their country. It'd also be a good platform for actors and actresses to speak out for or against the war. They are the real messengers of humanity, not the politicians.
Bratin, USA Yes and all enjoyment and laughter should be banned until the war 'ends'. Young pregnant ladies should be told to wait until after the war until they give birth, for fear of causing too much joy in this grim period. Get real!
Brian, Scotland
Due to the nature of the event I believe it should be postponed. Part of being able to deal with the war situation is getting on with your own life albeit in a more sombre and reflective way, but to hold this 'glitzy' event now would be grossly insensitive.
Stephen, UK
Never mix entertainment with politics. The world is still revolving; the show should still go on.
Sue, Yorkshire, England
is some star in an obscene dress more important than our troops? I think not |
No. Designer dresses, glitz, and all the rest exemplify to the rest of the world what is wrong with America. People are dieing, is some star in an obscene dress more important than our troops? I think not. Besides, the Hollywood liberals are just going to make anti-war speeches, so I for one am not going to tune in.
Bruce Squires, USA The Oscars shouldn't go on, there are a lot of problems and nobody will enjoy taking Oscars when there are civilians who are suffering. So let's think about suspending it until another time. God bless America and Britain.
Tenzing, India
One comment said 'war is war and entertainment is entertainment' - why is it then that we have to listen to celebrities shouting their mouths off about war all the time? As for the Oscars it is just a bunch of rich people patting other rich people on the back - hey why not? I mean men who are ten times what they are preparing to give their lives for freedom. I say cancel the Oscars forever and put the money to good use.
Yvonne Healan, UK
If the British people attended prom concerts, opera and ballet, music hall during the Blitz without a flinch, so can the Americans! Have their Oscar night.
Jeff Wright, USA
It is an important part of our culture and this shouldn't be stopped Mark Jordan, United Kingdom |
Yes, the troops would like us to carry on as normal. It is an important part of our culture and this shouldn't be stopped. It would be appropriate however, to dedicate a prayer to those affected by the conflict and pray for a quick victory in this conflict.
Mark Jordan, United Kingdom I think by now most of us should have realised how unimportant it is to award ourselves for the things we don't need to do. Do they have these award ceremonies in Iraq? No. This world needs a war, we are all becoming too greedy and self possessed. Cancel it.
Rob, UK
It would be shocking to hold the Oscars ceremony in the US at a time when this country is perpetrating one of the worst acts of terrorism since the World Trade Centre bombings.
Gevers, Belgium
I find the Oscars to be a total non-event at the best of times, and would normally gladly see them disappear. But I don't see why events in Iraq should make a difference. If they do, why stop at the Oscars? Perhaps all sports events, theatre performances and non-news programs on TV should be stopped, in case we all end up with guilty consciences for having the nerve to carry on with our lives and enjoy ourselves.
Alan, UK
Sure, and while we're at let's stop going out to dinner, watching sport, and having any sort of fun. In fact we should just sit around and look serious and grim faced at each other. What a question - as if the Oscars, and actors for that matter, are that important. Toned down? They should be turned off.
Tony, Hong Kong
I do not think it is the right time to party while people of Iraq are getting bombed - we have to support Will Smith and his decision.
Kris, Canada
They should go ahead - don't let this stand in the way. It should be over soon, but if it isn't then give them their awards - and if they don't stop the war yet at least they have something to cheer them up. Just think about it.
Jemma Bliss, England
I don't think they should go ahead, it isn't the time for shallow vanity |
The Oscars is always a load of celebrities saying "look at us we are a load of celebrities". I don't think they should go ahead, it isn't the time for shallow vanity.
Ben, UK Maybe I should stop going to school because I feel bad about the war. Or maybe my parents should stop going to work. Or how about un-stocking all violent films from the shops. My point is the world has to keep going even if there is a war. People will still think about the death and destruction in Iraq.
Ali Lee, UK
War is war while entertainment is entertainment. And life is life - so it must go on. We should not stop living our lives just because there is a war out there. Life should be celebrated while we can.
Maan T, UK
Of course the Oscars should go ahead. Don't let Saddam win on any scale. Everyone nominated has worked hard for recognition, why shouldn't they be rewarded? I just hope if it does go ahead, they won't use the stage for political purposes. Oscars represent entertainment - let's have an entertaining evening.
Andrea, UK
Definitely not, the fact the question is being asked in the first place shows to what extent we have lost sight of our core values as human beings. The thought of celebrating the achievements of charmed individuals, who exist on a level so far removed from the people of Iraq, just doesn't seem human!
Ben, Brit, living in Canada
Aren't the troops fighting for freedom to live a normal life out in Iraq? Rob Williams, Northwich, Cheshire |
There is a war going on and they are talking about cancelling the Oscars! Who cares? Personally though, I think the Oscars should go ahead, with the red carpet and the glamour. Aren't the troops fighting for freedom to live a normal life out in Iraq? Anyway, what difference does a red carpet make anyway?
Rob Williams, Northwich, Cheshire "Out of respect for the war"? Are you joking? The only reason the Oscars would be cancelled would be to prevent winners speaking out against the war. Let them run.
Andrew Dean, UK
I doubt all the people against 'such a party at this time' are staying at home this Friday and Saturday night. I guess it's OK to have a good time as long as you aren't a movie star. The two events are totally unrelated. I can go out have a laugh and a good time without forgetting the bravery of our soldiers and the loss of civilian life. Or are we supposed to stay in and mope until it's over?
Andy Cottier, London
It's just bad timing. Whichever way they swing there'll be criticism. I feel sorry for the organisers - they're damned if they do and they're damned if they don't.
Antonia, UK
Tom Hanks and a few others have it right by not attending the Oscars. They do not want to be part of a misguided, pampered elite turning a celebration into a political forum for anti-war protest. It is a time to show resolve and support for the Commander in Chief, not to publicly cut him down in public with less than honest motives. I will not watch the Oscars because of this.
Marcus, USA
I think it is totally inappropriate to hold the Oscars ceremony |
I think it is totally inappropriate to hold the Oscars ceremony at this time. I'm more concerned with what the Iraqi people and the US and UK soldiers are going through. The world has been turned upside down in the last 48 hours. Who really cares who wins what?
Sandi, Saudi Arabia (expat) I fail to understand any connection between the war and the Oscars. I am against this mixing of politics into every other arena of life, but if the stage is going to be used as just another platform to propagandize war, then we might as well not have them.
Nilesh, India
Had the US and UK not needed to go against the UN, I would have said go ahead with the Oscars, but I feel it may appear insensitive to the rest of the world. People against the US and UK decision will be waiting for an opportunity to condemn. I suggest a delay.
Ellie Roberts, UK
I live about 15-20minutes away from RNAS Culdrose where six crew members lost their lives this morning fighting for us. Shouldn't we all be thinking of more important matters and supporting our servicemen?
Christina, Cornwall, England
What the Oscars has to do with a war on Iraq is anyone's guess. What is certain is that a number of mindless windbag celebrities will no doubt use the event to make public their ill-informed and pointless views. Hollywood is as far removed from reality and political conflict as you can get.
Laina Kent, Australia
The red carpet should be rolled out without shame |
Not only should the Oscars go on as planned but the red carpet should be rolled out without shame. We turn to the cinema for distraction and escape and the Oscars is the granddad of the cinema. Give me glitzy gowns and red carpet, especially if the rest of the time I'm taxed with bombs and war.
Chris, USA It's just one more "reality TV" show with contrived people doing contrived things in an effort to gain ratings share. In effect, could I care less?
Kim Privette, USA
In the past I have looked forward to the Oscars. This year I don't give a damn. Not because of the war with Iraq, but because of the actors that are going to use this platform to get on their soap box. What makes them think they are more qualified then the average citizen? Actually they are less qualified. Most of them have no more then a high school education, but because they are famous they think that gives them special rights.
Barbara Orput, California
Bush and Blair should get a joint best actor Oscar for their lead roles in "Organ Grinder and the Monkey".
Zorba Eisenhower, UK
Cancelling the Oscars because of the war will not mean much but if the Oscars are cancelled in protest against the war it will say much more. If celebrities are truly concerned about this war and the impact on the Iraqi and American people then this would be a good chance for them to speak out.
Mary, USA
A person may win an Oscar award and give an anti-war speech that may offend some viewers, especially troops' families |
It is appropriate to cancel the Oscars at this time of war. I support President Bush and British troops. A person may win an Oscar award and give an anti-war speech that may offend some viewers, especially troops' families.
Bryan Herbert, USA I fail to see the connection between the two events. People die from Aids in Africa every day and from repression and torture in the Middle East. Celebrity events never got cancelled before. Why now?
Shauna, UK
It should go ahead only if the stars wear anti-war regalia and use the occasion to speak out against war.
JD, Madison, USA
I think it's ironic that the same anti-war celebrities, who think the US government is making up the whole notion that Saddam is a threat, want the National Guard to protect the Oscars ceremony. Do they really think they matter that much to Iraqis? Talk about egocentric.
Janice, Virginia, USA
Let us not be so caught up in the misery of the situation that we forget to enjoy and commend those who deserve and have earned their day of celebration. |
Should high school dances be cancelled? College graduations? Weddings? Events have been planned to celebrate the goodness and greatness of individuals in our world. Let us not be so caught up in the misery of the situation that we forget to enjoy and commend those who deserve and have earned their day of celebration.
Desiree, USA I think it should go on because it is celebrating the things that happened before the war. Life does go on no matter what happens.
Nadia Ali- Shahumi, England UK
I am concerned about the soliders not what award some overpaid actor or actress wins.
Dee, USA
The Oscar ceremony should go ahead. I believe that to let the Iraq crisis stop it going ahead would somehow add legitimacy to Saddam and his pursuit of power.
Stephen Quinlan, Ireland
I think that for the sake of our sanity and that of our children everything should remain as normal as possible, including the Oscars. I will be watching the show and will still be praying for the people in Iraq, both armed forces and the Iraqi people.
Phil Johnson, NY, USA
The Oscars should be postponed to a later date just like the Emmys were after 9/11.
April Levine, USA
Cancelling the Oscars will do nothing towards cancelling the war |
The show must go on, as they say. Cancelling the Oscars will do nothing towards cancelling the war. Shall we all stop going to the pub on a Friday evening or watching TV because everything seems so less important now we are at war? A strength the people of Britain had during the two World Wars was to carry on regardless. The Oscars should take a leaf out this book.
Caz , London Although we need entertainment even in hard times to warm our hearts, this kind of entertainment is out of place. We will be left to contemplate a bunch of people who are self-obsessed and over-paid while our troops are not.
Agnes, UK
The event should be postponed. This is not a time for glamour or pretence. Our boys are out there with and our thoughts should be with them and their sacrifices until they return. It isn't fun to be out in desert conditions.
Pretty Sterling, Los Angeles, California
The Oscars should not go on as planned. If they did, the message to people everywhere would be that many Americans oppose this war. Even the rich and famous should be willing to stop business as usual in solidarity for anti-war activists.
Brooke Wright, USA
There will be a sentiment of sadness Cristina Castro, Costa Rica |
I think the show should go on taking into account that there must be more safety. There will be a sentiment of sadness though.
Cristina Castro, Costa Rica Our heroes should be the men and women who voluntarily signed up to risk their lives to free Iraq. They deserve an Oscar and our respect for their performance.
Joe Mode, USA
Bad timing Mr Bush. How can it go ahead? It would be in the utmost of bad taste.
Pamela Harries, London
The show should be temporarily put off. Awards are far less important than lives lost in battle.
Trisha, Dhaka
Who would want to watch the Oscars while war is going on? Everyone is tuned into the news channels 24/7.
Mrs Riyami, Oman
People in Iraq, on both sides, have much more to worry about than whether or not the Oscar ceremony is appropriate |
Just like any other highly visible public event security should be appropriate and the event should go on as usual. I think the organisers are over estimating the importance of the whole thing. People in Iraq, on both sides, have much more to worry about than whether or not the Oscar ceremony is appropriate.
Anthony, USA As much as I would like to be positive and say that the Oscars should go ahead I find myself thinking that if it is going to be morbid and toned-down it should be cancelled. The Oscars are a celebration of talented people and should be put on hold for happier times when it can be appreciated.
Sarah Millns, England
We need to focus on other things than the war. Life goes on as they say. In fact I'm fed up of hearing about the war.
Laura Simmons, UK
The Oscar ceremony is a party and we cannot simply amuse ourselves and just pretend that the war is not taking place |
The Oscars should be postponed at least for some weeks. Despite all the discussion about this US-led war, the academy should show respect to people who die in Iraq. The Oscar ceremony is a party and we cannot simply amuse ourselves and just pretend that the war is not taking place.
Irene Heynemann, Brazil I say the Oscars should be celebrated with more fanfare and jubilation than any other time. I can't think of a more appropriate match for the self-promoting and self-riotous Blair-Bush combo. If these two can do it, let the actors do it too. At the least we know their acting is harmless!
SB, USA
At this moment in both of our histories, the Oscars are the last thing on my mind, especially when it will become a soapbox for the anti-war group. I couldn't really care less what movie or actor wins when both of our countries, men and women, are dying just so that they can shoot their mouths off and have the luxury of nothing happening to them for their comments.
Marie Keim, USA
Yes they should go ahead and they should award Bush, Blair and Saddam the prize for worst clown show of the century.
Markos Martiolakis, Greece
They should go on as scheduled! World War II did not stop the Oscars, why should we let this? Press ahead!
Steve Wood, USA
If the actors start with their opinions for or against the war, I will turn it OFF.
Bonnie Smith, USA
I think we should all carry on as normal, if we don't that means Saddam will see this as he is winning. We should carry on and show him that everything is just fine and dandy here.
Elizabeth Francis, England
If the Oscars go ahead, it lets the so called terrorists know that they cannot push us around, but it also tells them what our true values are. Why should an awards show be more important to us than real life and real people? Just hand the awards out, and skip the pomp and ceremony.
Donna, Canada
The Oscars should go ahead because it shows we appreciate the many talented people |
Yes I believe the Oscars should go ahead because it shows we appreciate the many talented people that there are in the world, even though we are at war.
Jonny Carnell, England How petty a worry. Life goes on, doesn't it. Just think; while you put on your fancy gowns and tuxedos, while you sip champagne and think of yourself winning an award - think of all the people trying to win something the majority of the world don't want them to even have started. Carry on, but do not forget.
Kelly, UK
I think that the Oscars should go ahead as planned. We all need to go on with our day to day living and focus on the task ahead, and leave the war to the armies.
Dwain Winston Pearce, Tortola
Yes, cancel it. They are all full of their own self importance anyway. The awards will be used for them to get on their soap boxes and start preaching about the war. When will they realise they got their Oscars for Acting NOT politics.
Jacqui, UK
Definitely NOT, I think it is appalling that the Oscars are still going ahead when WAR is on - THINK ABOUT IT!
Zoe Eveleigh, England
No, the Oscars should not go ahead. It's a display of pomp and pageantry at a time when there is a very sobering war going on. I also think it would be disheartening to the troops to hear these fluff people making anti-war comments, as has happened during previous years. The American people do not care about their political views.
Sherry Rice, USA
I can't stand the Oscars ceremony and would be happy to see it cancelled for any number of reasons, but not this one |
Yes, the Oscars should go ahead. I know people will say it's "disrespectful" but how can you single out the Oscars as the event that should be cancelled. How about other awards ceremonies, or sporting spectacles such as football, ice hockey and basketball, or the start of the baseball season. I think the ceremony should be toned down, and also now is not the time for political posturing by movie stars in acceptance speeches, but to cancel the whole ceremony would be absurd. By the way, I can't stand the Oscars ceremony and would be happy to see it cancelled for any number of reasons, but not this one.
Robin Johnston, England I must say that I have turned my back on several of these Hollywood types, just as they have turned their back on this country. Do not get me wrong, I sincerely believe that they have free speech just like the next person, however I have problems with the manner in which some of these folks have expressed themselves. A few of them have resorted to character attacks verses policy debate, I find that counterproductive. So, with this in mind, I could care less if they have their little parade and ceremony. I shall never view them and their movies again one way or the other.
R. Bunner, USA
It is my understanding that the stars will forgo the lush red carpet this year allowing their pampered celebrity feet to feel the shock of the pavement through their $1200 shoes. What brave troopers they are. In view of this monumental sacrifice, let�s shower them with praise and glory as they look down their noses at us, the great unwashed masses, when they pass by in their bullet proof limos (these vehicles are, of course, in line with the environmental causes that are so dear to Hollywood) Yes, the show must go on; It is SO important in these times.
Shawn, USA
They could wait for the outcome of the war, that USA claims will be over in weeks |
If the Oscar will go on it will be another proof that USA does not care about people that die at this very moment in Iraq. Actors deserve this moment, but they could wait for the outcome of the war, that USA claims will be over in weeks.
Vladislav Firsov, Russia Does anyone really think that the Oscars are as important at the war that is going on right now? The Oscars is a bit of fluff with a bunch of ridiculous celebs walking around in their beautiful little fantasy world. Then, they would insult the rest of us by standing there in their glitz, making anti-war statements? What a joke! No, the Oscars should not go on. If they do, there should be no political speeches and the dress should be very toned down. The US is at war and these people should show some respect for our troops who are living in the real world, fighting a real war.
Sherry R., USA
It's a sad reflection on the western consumerist way of life that we should just act 'normally', though troops are risking life and limb for our well-being. In this respect the Oscars should still go on, but let's hope no-one uses them as any basis to voice their views on the war. Such an instance would undermine the whole social significance of 'entertainment'.
Jonathan B-Jones, England
It's absolute blind hysteria Elizabeth Bond, Bristol, England |
There is absolutely no reason for the Academy Awards to be cancelled or postponed. Nor is there any need to tone them down. While it is, of course, a right to voice opposition, I can't help thinking that people are jumping on a bandwagon of Anti-war ranting. Entertainment has absolutely no connection to politics and if celebrities do want to say they are against war, that is their right but it should not get in the way of a completely unrelated issue. It's absolute blind hysteria.
Elizabeth Bond, Bristol, England The argument that the Oscars should be halted is as stupid as this illegal and immoral war. After all stars have been flaunting their obscenely expensive jewels and dresses for years, oblivious to any conflict or the terrible poverty that has inflicted billions across the world. Why should it change this year? They would do it next year with no shame despite global suffering and would rightly be deemed hypocrites. Besides I need to see the dresses and emotional speeches to cheer me up in these awful times!
Talented ND, UK
My opinion is no, no, and no! I feel our National Guard should be protecting the country and all its citizens, not a select group. They should spend their own money for security and protection, not the tax payers!
Mary Doyle, USA
This is just another example of how out of touch celebrities really are. |
This is just another example of how out of touch celebrities really are. First they pat themselves on the back for cancelling the "red carpet," but then they declare how they plan to use their time to talk as a political forum. Of course this is after most all of them have been saying for weeks, how much they support our troops! I doubt any of them have ever even met a soldier, but suffice it to say, they aren't too appreciative of their "support."
Brendan, USA I don't know whether or not the Oscars should go on. And I really don't care. What I care about is the total lack of patriotism the "stars" have shown. Do they even realize what this war is all about or is this just another soapbox for them to get on. Are they even aware of all the inhumane things that bastard Saddam has done to us as well as his own people. Do they believe that he should be allowed to continue this evil behaviour? What is wrong with them? I am ashamed and embarrassed that they call themselves Americans. I am an American. I support our president completely and without question. He is a CHRISTIAN man with Christian values. These stars call themselves anti-war. Well President Bush is anti-war also, but he knows what has to be done to eliminate the evil in this world that threatens all of us. Get with the American program or get out. You won't be missed.
Tina Cansler, USA
Yes they should go on. The Oscars are for men and women whom have worked hard and gave us all entertainment through the year. They deserve their awards. Plus we all need something to help take our minds, if only for an hour, off what is going on in Iraqi - if possible.
Marjorie, USA
It would be extremely disrespectful to the citizens of Iraq to hold a party for movie celebrities |
No, I do not think the Oscar's should go ahead. It would be extremely disrespectful to the citizens of Iraq to hold a party for movie celebrities at a time when many Iraqis fear for their lives. As a demonstration of respect the red carpets and the self-congratulatory speeches should not go ahead.
Sean Doran, Canada NO, out of respect they should not air the Oscars. There are far more important things going on in the world than to pay attention to some overpaid, strutting peacocks.
Rae, USA
Of course they should go ahead, I would not want living to stop if I should die.
Fran Williamson, England
Let's hear it for Arnie, who said: "I think it's a good idea to try to eliminate the red carpet and also try to eliminate all the political speeches." You mean the anti-war speeches, of course, don't you, Arnie? Democracy really is dying in the Bush age. Let's start scared if this is the future of the West.
Dave Mitchell, UK
the Oscars has nothing to do with politics, they are here to entertain people |
Well, knowing that some of the actors that are against war haven't been called for the Oscar ceremony; they should immediately postpone it. However i believe that the Oscars has nothing to do with politics, they are here to entertain people. This is the time that we need cheered up!
Firat, Cyprus/UK The Oscars ceremony would be the perfect opportunity for those opposed to this ludicrous war to make their voices heard. So yes, it should go ahead as usual.
Mark, Canada
I think the Oscars should be cancelled as a mark of respect to the soldiers. How can people want to party and celebrate when there are so many more important issues to focus on? Cancelling the Oscars will not be a "victory" for Saddam but a triumph for the US to show that they are fully behind their soldiers. The Oscars can always be rescheduled - the war cannot.
Amma Boamah, England
I think the Oscars should go ahead. The news is going to be saturated with war coverage for however long the conflict lasts, so whatever light relief can be provided should be. All I ask is that no stars make politically motivated speeches regarding the war - it should be one programme which makes as little reference to the "real world" as possible.
Adam, England
It would appear the US and UK have gone to war to defend their citizens' rights to watch TV |
It would appear from many of the comments posted here, that the US and UK have gone to war to defend their citizens' rights to watch entertaining TV.
V, Hong Kong There seems little reason in cancelling the awards ceremony. For people who say it is insensitive to have awards while people are dying, I would like to point out that the US media is using this war as some form of a circus to attract more TV viewers, especially with all the details of what their "MOABs" and B-52s can do. Is it more humane to rejoice about what arsenal you possess when it is just being used to kill innocent people? And all this just for oil.
Vicky, India
Should the Oscars take place at all, even in peacetime? That's the real question.
S Jacques, Pakistan
The Oscars should go ahead, as it's a good way to take people's minds off war. It's so gloomy to talk so much about war. The Bush administration is not the centre of the world. War's just a huge mess!
T Huyen, Vietnam
We have to prove to each other that we can still live normal lives amidst the war |
I think they should push thru with the show. We have to prove to each other that we can still live normal lives amidst the war. Cancelling the show would just prove to speculators that indeed, the war is successful in destroying all of us.
Darcy, Philippines The war should not hinder our daily lives. In doing so, we give terrorists and Hussein a victory they don't deserve - defining our life and actions according to their insanity. May the war end soon, and the Two Towers win best film.
Anthony Lupo, Pusan, Korea
Does anybody really care that a bunch of backslappers go ahead and make fools of themselves? All I say is, you carry on with your 'entertaining' and keep your thoughts of more 'worldly things' to yourselves.
Selwyn Humphreys, USA
I am a little more concerned with the war than some whining actors |
I hope they just cancel it. I am a little more concerned with the war than some whining actors that care more about what they are wearing to the event and giving themselves even more awards.
Brian Bronson, Canada The Oscars are a celebration of achievements by people in the entertainment industry. To make movies is their job. Does your job stop because there is a war? I didn't think so. So why should theirs?
Jaime Henry, USA
The Oscars represent men who play heroes on film. War represents men who are heroes. Let's put the Oscars on hold for a while.
MG, UK
I for one would appreciate the opportunity to spend one night in complete escapism |
I think it is somewhat hypocritical - to say the least - of stars to cite 'people dying' as a reason not to host the Oscars. There were people dying this time last year when they all 'grinned and waved' - is it just that this time they feel it is personal? I for one would appreciate the opportunity to spend one night in complete escapism watching the glamour and the gushing!
Lindsey, UK No, it seems rather sick to me to be revelling when thousands are about to die horribly... but they will go ahead anyway...
Conall O'Connor, Ireland
What on earth have the Oscars got to do with a war on the other side of the world?!! Why would you even contemplate banning them? Who exactly is meant to benefit from such a move? Certainly, not the people of Iraq. I could turn the question around, and ask why shouldn't the Oscars go ahead? And why shouldn't there be the usual razzamatazz? This pathetic, touchy-feely posturing smacks of an angst-ridden establishment trying to appease its guilty conscience.
Jason King, England
No they shouldn't. But then, my view is not influenced in any way by the war in Iraq. I'd use any excuse to stop this overblown self- congratulatory nonsense.
DavidM, London, UK
I think the organisers should postpone it for a while - it's our people and the US people out there - they should have some respect!
Rose, UK
If we were to cancel the ceremony every time there was a war on in the world there would have never been an "Oscars" |
Of course the Oscars should go ahead. For 'stars' to say things like "it seems inappropriate at a time when people are dying" is so narrow minded. Are people only dying now because America is at war? If we were to cancel the ceremony every time there was a war on in the world there would have never been an "Oscars". Let's just get on with it and see who wins best actress!
Nicola, UK Yes, i believe that the Oscars should take place because we have to try and carry on with normal life. I agree with the fact that there should be no seating outside for the public in case of terrorist attacks.
Carly Hutchinson, Wales
Why shouldn't they, they say in this era of terror that we shouldn't let the blighters win by being afraid, so get out there and do your jobs starlets! I think the burning issue here is, why on earth Andy Serkis wasn't nominated for best supporting actor for his role of Gollum in The Two Towers? Outrage! See, we recognise the real issues here in Blighty!
Matty, UK
they should not be celebrating when innocent people and soldiers are giving their lives for their countries Crystal Topolinsky, Canada |
I don't think the Oscars should go ahead right now. Even though I enjoy watching them, I feel they should not be celebrating when innocent people and soldiers are giving their lives for their countries! It just wouldn't be appropriate!
Crystal Topolinsky, Canada I think with respect to so many innocent human lives at stake, it would be inhuman to have entertainment.
Abdul Haadi, USA
I think that the Oscars should absolutely continue as planned. The main objective of terrorists and dictators is to evoke fear to get their point across. We cannot let them control our lives. We must show them that America is still a strong country. Plus, I am completely against this war, and believe we shouldn't go patronizing the Bush administration in any way for what they have done. It's all just one huge mess.
Clementine, USA
Why should the whole world come to a standstill just because of thoughtless terrorists? |
The Oscars should definitely go ahead. Why should the whole world come to a standstill just because of thoughtless terrorists? It's what they want, don't give in.
Sian Hyett, Wales No, I totally disagree, why should the Oscars go head? The majority of the nation didn't want war to go ahead! We must remember that there are soldiers out dying, from what I can see for no reason! Obviously humanity is dead...long live celebrities!
Donna, N.Ireland
Why miss this opportunity for these "artists" to make fools of themselves?
Bill Carter, USA
Yes, we need to continue our daily activities - after all that is why we are fighting. For the freedom to live a normal life. If we stop doing normal activities then the reason to fight becomes clouded. In this readers opinion we should support all allied forces and recognize their efforts, but should continue to live as they would want us to.
Chris Houren, USA
The awards need to go on. Just as life should. I certainly don't want to watch the war, that's for sure. What will the US postpone next - the elections? It certainly seems that way now.
Ginger Winchester, United States
Of course they should go ahead, keep politics out of it. But I think the troops could do with some moral support - they are there on duty.
Di, UK
The Oscar ceremony should be as bold and as flash as it normally is. It's what people need right now - not some depressing, sombre event. I'm sick of the assumption that just because the long awaited war has started we're all not allowed to have any fun.
Tim, USA (expat)
The extensive media coverage of this "should they go ahead or not" issue is wildly inflating the supposed importance of the Oscars. Film awards are no big deal!
Lorraine, England
Nobody can have fun and celebrate when there is war |
Definitely NOT! They should stop the war! Nobody can have fun and celebrate when there is war, i feel there participants should boycott the whole Oscar issue. Please, i should take this opportunity to oppose the WAR.
Priscilla, Malawi Of course they should go ahead! And the ceremony shouldn't be toned down either! We as a general public cannot control the fact there is a war going on, so we want normality whilst we can. People want to see the glam and glitz - a reason to take their mind of an otherwise worrying time!
Dave Young, UK
Cancel the Oscars. Just hand out the awards to the people who won them and do away with the pageantry. The Oscars aren't about the show as much as they're about the box office boost to the winners. I dislike the idea of celebrating while people like my brother, US Army 707th Ordnance (bomb squad) are dodging bullets and rockets in Iraq.
Ted Stalcup, United States
Why not? Why should we let lousy old Saddam stop one of our greatest events?
Chris, USA
Cancel it. It wouldn't be missed. Self congratulation has no meaning.
Robert, UK
Of course they should! It's light entertainment, a bit of froth, innit? It's supposed to take our minds off the war, and give us something to gawp at! The stars know they are on parade - it's a work night for them, they are here to entertain us. The last thing they need is to be told is that they are somehow of national importance, and therefore have to be toned down or banned outright.
John, UK
I thnk they should go ahead, and I hope many of the winners have the courage to stand up and denounce this atrocity by Bush and Blair.
SS, Scotland
If they cannot behave in a supportive manner of the British and American troops, I would postpone them. These pampered people make their living pretending to be someone else, and some belittle our president's intellect because they don't like his politics, and that is a disgrace. Doug Patton
Vinnie, USA
There are wars going on all over the world. People die from disease or starvation in unthinkable numbers. There wouldn't have been an Oscars night in the last 50 years if the industry as a whole was so concerned about this. Go back to your multi-million dollar contracts and arguing about who gets the biggest trailer.
Ian, England
One-Minute World News 
News services
Email this to a friend 
Printable version 
