Tony Blair has suffered a second backbench rebellion over plans for military action against Iraq - but the result is not as damaging as some had predicted. Four hundred and twelve MPs voted in favour of the government's policy.
However, a separate motion saying the case for war hadn't yet been established was supported by 217 MPs - as many as 139 of them Labour backbenchers.
Who is your MP? Are you happy with how they voted? Do you think Mr Blair's gamble on Iraq has paid off, or is his future still uncertain?
Thank you for your e-mails. This debate is now closed. A selection of your comments is published below.
The following comments reflect the balance of views we have received:
Good decision by our MPs, it amazes me that all these people are so concerned about the human rights of asylum seekers, but couldn't care less about the human right violations that Saddam imposes on his own people; let's liberate them now.
Paul Curtis, UK
My MP, Brian White sits on a wafer thin majority here and abstained. Because of the tightness of the contest here I have always voted Labour, despite my problems with aspects of Tony Blair's policies. I am, however, outraged by this. The government is going to war in clear contravention of international law. I do not consider my own MP's abstention as sufficient, and will be voting Liberal Democrat (at least until Labour MPs gain the courage to remove Tony Blair).
Mark, Milton Keynes, UK
 The rebels' cause is lost  |
My MP voted against the rebel amendment. Thank goodness for her common sense! The prime minister shouldn't be vilified. He's the hero of the piece. The rebels should undergo a 'self reality check' - it's Saddam who is the actual villain. The government motion passed with an impressive 73.5% majority. The rebels' cause is lost. They were misguided, and they can now sit back and watch the popularity in the country soar. Let's all rally round and support our troops as they put their lives on the line in the name of freedom.
Bill, UK Big business, greed and ambition decide how our MPs vote. Our democracy is a sham, as is the USA's.
David Stanley, UK
Patrick Hall is my MP. I am very disappointed he chose not to back the PM. I fully support the government's stance on Iraq but I am disappointed the UN has failed to recognise the threat Saddam poses to not only his own people but the world in general. I believe the PM will become stronger as a result of his strong stand.
Len Sharpe, UK
Now that our families have been deployed I will not tell them they are risking their lives in vain |
My heart is broken and I am very scared for what is about to transpire today and for the ensuing weeks and years to come. I honestly believe our leaders are doing what they believe to be the best for the world - I simply do not agree with them. However, now that our families have been deployed I will not tell them they are risking their lives in vain. I can only give them my full support and hope for their safe and expedient return. Our governments have spoken and now we must support our leaders who have very important decisions to make in the days to come. Mr Blair, Mr Bush you have our futures in your hands. Please be careful what you do.
Tracy, US The MPs had to make a tough decision on whether or not to obey orders from the PM or whether to vote against him. I think it all depended on how strongly they felt on the issue. I think it shows how strongly Robin Cook and the other MPs felt when they resigned from the government so that they would not have the moral issue of going against their boss. I think it also shows a great deal of courage for the Tory MPs that voted against their leader. Personally I feel war is necessary, BUT I do think we need other countries on board. If this means waiting for a second resolution so be it!
Stuart Rae, UK
Yes, MPs should support the prime minister - it is clear the French sabotaged the peace process for reasons of their own. My MP (Jim Marshell) was a rebel, but I am going to write to tell him that IF I vote for him next time, it will be to support Tony Blair's government - not his decisions to support Saddam in House of Commons.
Dr Garrick Fincham, UK
I find it most annoying to see people here writing as if the House has completely ignored the will of the British people. Do they not realise that there are many of us who DO wish to see Saddam ousted, who DO want to send a firm message to would be dictators and terrorists, who DO want to uphold the will of the UN as expressed in its countless unheeded resolutions? The anti-war camp may shout more loudly than the pro-camp, but its convictions are held no less strongly.
Sam, N�mes, France
All the MPs who voted for this war will have blood on their hands |
This is a very sad day for England. I am against the war and feel proud of the MPs who voted against it. It takes courage to stand up and be counted and even lose your job. All the MPs who voted for this (unjust) war will have blood on their hands - including Clare Short, and I feel it will destabilise our world.
Noreen McAllen, England YES - there is no alternative - words have not worked - Saddam has made the weapons inspectors' job impossible.
Anne, UK
Last night's vote confirms my view that the politicians are not representative of the views of the British public |
In the last two general elections I have spoiled my ballot paper as an indication that I am interested in politics, but feel that the political parties and politicians' agendas simply do not represent my values and views. Last night's vote confirms my view that the politicians are not representative of the views of the British public. A tragic day.
Graham, UK I believe MPs were right to back Tony Blair. I am amazed at how few people give any thought to the conditions of the people of Iraq over the past 20 years and the fact that the United Nations has been defied constantly by the Iraqi regime since 1991.
Jacqui Carter, England
Tony Blair is lucky. That is all that can be said. He took a gamble and won but at what price for his future position? Despite the fact the majority of his party appear to back him, his country still doesn't and he'd never get away with war if it were down to the general public. He is playing puppet for George Bush and in turn is losing a great deal of respect for his party from the voters.
Amy, UK
We simply cannot afford to stand back and do nothing |
I am not a Labour voter, but he has my backing. We must rid the world of Saddam and protect the future peace for all mankind. We simply cannot afford to stand back and do nothing, or otherwise Saddam and others like him will stop at nothing to gain world dominance through terrorism and other evil means. It is a case of if we do not get him, he will get us.
Alison Dow, Scotland Yes it's about time action was taken; Saddam has had more than enough time.
Clive Sweeting, England
I am pleased that my MP (Huw Edwards - Monmouth) has continued his opposition to our going to war, but am saddened that the wishes of so many of the British people are being overridden. There has been an appalling failure of diplomacy and Britain has put itself into a position of great difficulty with some of its EU partners. We need to continue to do business as partners with France and Germany and the government will have a great deal of work to do to right this situation.
Mark Pendleton, UK
He has shown great moral courage in the face of intense pressure |
History often proves that what appears to be majority public opinion often proves to be a noisy and reactive minority - over 80% of my friends, work colleagues and acquaintances are behind Mr Blair. I believe that he has shown great moral courage in the face of intense pressure from those that would appease a brutal dictator. Once the people of Iraq are liberated, their thanks will be clear for the whole world to see. However, let's not forget we must follow up properly with aid.
Mike, UK I'm disgusted with the way my MP (and PM) has led this. Why are we pursuing Mr Bush's war in Iraq when our own trains don't run? Where is the money coming from? More to the point however is if we are going to war we need pray that the casualties are minimal, and let's hope his gamble pays off.
Dave, Newton Aycliffe, Durham, England
People say our intentions and reasons for the war are unclear and misguided. The truth is that for any one of the many reasons; weapons of mass destruction, humanitarian reasons, risk of merging Saddam's weapons with extremists. All these are reason enough ALONE, never mind together.
Dominic Clifford, UK
Being damned or not as an MP or PM for acting to avoid war is no argument for war. It was not a vote on some piece of minor UK policy. It was a vote against seeking peaceful resolutions and not for personal status. More countries are against than for! No UN backing. No mandate for war.
M Jones, Oxon, UK.
I feel a number of MPs voted against their better judgement; I do not doubt that Saddam Hussein is in breach of UN resolutions, and that his people suffer but does that now mean that we are going to go to war with all other oppressive regimes and those that do not comply with UN resolutions? I could go on! The whole process has made me feel powerless if we live in a democracy why did no one listen to us?
Maxine Phillips, England
War is the only option. Many innocent civilians will die but think of the outcome in Iraq in the future; no longer will they need to abide by Saddam's rules but live a free life of happiness.
Josie Conyard, England
I am ashamed on their behalf for not voting against this illegal war |
I am ashamed on their behalf for not voting against this illegal war. Just to support the troops was the argument, but it's not genuine. Hypocrisy is the main characteristic of this conflict anyway, so they just carry on the tradition. They failed to stand up to the historic moment and history will judge them accordingly. I wonder how they sleep at night with the eyes of thousands of dead Iraqi children staring at them.
George, Ashford, Kent, UK What true British courage to stand up to evil like Saddam even without UN backing.
James Pearson, UK
I have disagreed with Tony Blair on nearly everything he has done since he became prime minister, but on this issue, he is right and gets my full support. In a time of war, normal politics should be put to one side and the country should stand firmly behind its leaders. There is a moral case for this war, so far I have not heard a moral case for leaving the evil dictator Saddam Hussein in power.
Graeme, UK
I'm very disappointed my MP voted against the amendment |
I'm very disappointed to note that my MP, Ian Pearson, voted against the amendment, particularly as I was one of the many members of the Dudley South Constituency Labour Party that worked long and hard, delivering leaflets and canvassing electors to get him elected in the first place. I don't believe that this war is right and just - the weapons inspectors themselves are reported to be very angry at being pulled out at this stage because they felt they were getting results - albeit slowly. I believe we should have listened to them and not the rhetoric that's coming out of the White House.
Di Holland, UK My MP, John Bercow a previously outspoken critic of both the Tory leadership and the government obviously fell into line with party pressure and the desire to keep his job rather than reflect the opinion of his constituency and his self portrayal as a profoundly religious family man. We will see the impact of this in the forthcoming local elections and in the general election. He and his party will not get my vote again. But, then none of the others will either. Government in this country needs some real statesmen or stateswomen that actually listen to the people.
Peter, Buckingham, UK
I did not vote for Mr Blair, but he has been excellent in this crisis |
Last night on the BBC news saw an English lesson at a school where the children were being told to write a letter to Downing Street to oppose the war - am I the only appalled by this indoctrination? I did not vote for Mr Blair, but he has been excellent in this crisis. The country must stand behind the troops on this now.
Jon, UK I am saddened and dismayed by the comments "The debate is over now, we must get behind our troops". This is exactly what the government planned, once the bombs start to drop everyone will forget that this is an illegal and unjust war. I for one will be voting against my local MP for his stance on Iraq, in the upcoming Scottish elections.
Grant Robertson, Scotland
I shall not be backing any military action against Iraq. Our PM is being controlled by the US. The UN should have been given full backing and the Inspectors given time to do there jobs properly.
Stuart Cross, UK
We should support our troops that protect us and the rest of the world from vicious dictators that compromise world security. It seems to be more of a fashion statement to be anti-war rather than actually facing up to facts over the last decade. More Iraqi people want the war than us. Imagine having no freedom of speech, we wouldn't be having this pole right now under Saddam's ruling! Well done Mr Blair for standing up for what is just and correct, you have my full backing.
Adrian English, Isle of Man
Finally it shows that Tony's own government is behind him and now we can go to war sort this out once and for all |
I was very glad to see that my MP did vote with the Government. Finally it shows that Tony's own Government is behind him and now we can go to war sort this out once and for all. I would just like to wish everyone going into battle "Good Luck" and may you return safely to families in the not too distant future.
Dane Holden, England I'm amused at the concept that some folks seem to think that this government (and its vote) represent Britons fairly. Judging by the half-hearted pro-war demonstrations around the world it certainly seems that politicians are as out-of-touch as ever, and a small proportion of the populace are deluded by their stance.
Richard Blake-Reed, Bath, UK
I was saddened that the amendment did not succeed but a little comforted knowing my MP, Tony Wright, had supported the amendment. I agree the case for war has not been established - it is currently not the least evil option or the last resort - diplomatic efforts should continue!
Richard, Staffordshire, England
I'm glad my MP voted for action against Iraq. The case for action has been proved many times over in the last decades, Saddam should have been dealt with in the last Gulf War, he is a menace to his own people and to the world. We should not allow psychopathic people like him the privilege of rule. It is our duty in the name of humanity to get rid of him and his sons from that country.
Chris, UK
They are certainly not representing the people who put them there |
Is it democratic to have the majority of the people in this country against the war and the majority of the MPs (elected by those same people!) supporting the war? They are certainly not representing the people who put them there for that sole purpose, and their vote yesterday marked a shameful day in the British democracy.
Snezana Nelson, UK Let's be proud of what our PM has done. He never gave up on any of his morals and never succumbed to the disloyal Left who have a history of jumping at any opportunity. I just hope the likes of George Galloway and Robin Cook will be ignored by those MPs on both sides of the House who believe what we are doing is just. Let's be proud that it is our country taking this stand unlike those cowards from across the Channel.
Matthew, UK
British troops deserve better than to be dragooned into America's dangerous and unnecessary adventure in the Gulf. The greatest support we can show them is to campaign to stop this war and withdraw British forces immediately.
Gordon Nardell, UK
Tony Blair and George Bush have shown courage during these last months, putting their political careers on the line |
As a British citizen living in America, it grieves me to see how many in the UK view George Bush. He is a good man, doing what he believes is the right thing. To say this is all part of "revenge" for 9/11 shows lack of knowledge. Tony Blair and George Bush have shown courage during these last months, putting their political careers on the line. Perhaps if we lived in Iraq, we here in America and UK would show more support and respect for these two leaders who have chosen to stand on Morals and not on world opinion. It's a sad day to think standing on principle doesn't count for anything any more.
Linda Rivera, USA I too, Linda Rivera, USA, am a Briton in America but your TV seems to show a different George Bush to mine! I see a typical posturing, self-promoting politician who has not explained the connection between Iraq and 9/11, or why Iraq has been left alone for a decade and is now to be attacked. Also, his speeches would be clearer if uncluttered by references to imaginary deities.
Nigel Rees, USA
OK, bad things happen, but our country and allies fought and won two world wars against dictators with threats of and acts of terrorism. It has to stop. Get rid of the problem once and for all and our children can grow up in a more peaceful world. Let's look after what we have. Because it's not going to last forever. Life's too short. Love to all my family and friends.
Marc, UK
It is obvious that the situation we are now at is the only way forward. I do not believe that Mr Blair or Mr Straw have reached this point lightly. As a nation that is built on democratic principles, now is the time for us all to accept the situation and unite under a cause that will hopefully achieve the level of progress that is materialising in Afghanistan.
Andrew Piddington, Wales
Some of our elected representatives are willing to stand by their beliefs and those of their constituents |
My MP Valerie Davey, for Bristol West, voted for the rebel amendment for which I was grateful - it shows that some of our elected representatives are willing to stand by their beliefs and those of their constituents. I was concerned though to hear that not all MPs were willing to do so and felt the need to vote against their own beliefs due to pressure or fear for their careers - that is certainly not the sign of true democracy; that glorious prize for which we are fighting in Iraq.
Hannah Hitchens, England My MP, Tom Brake, did not vote with the government and therefore did not represent my views. I am 100% behind Tony Blair. History will be the true judge.
John Littlewood, UK
Do I "support our troops" now that they're to go into battle? That depends what you mean. I won't stop paying the taxes which buy them their weapons. I won't try to bomb them, or sell secrets to the Iraqis. I won't, however, renounce peace and throw my morals out simply because fighting will certainly start.
Paul, UK
I totally support Tony Blair and his MPs should be ashamed of themselves for not getting more behind him. What is the point of having a leader if not to let him lead? It is obvious Tony Blair is not a warmonger. I'm disgusted with Robin Cook for resigning at this time, I did have a great respect for him but not any more!
Yvonne Walsh, UK
What use is the public voice when whatever Blair wants to do he will just do? |
What's the point of having a democratic country when the definition of the term democracy has been lost in Britain? What use is the public voice when whatever Blair wants to do he will just do?
Shelly, England I simply do not believe that any Labour MPs actually believe the rhetoric of Tony Blair. I think the MPs who supported the government are an appalling shower of cynical cowards who did not have the courage to stand up to bullying by Blair and his whips. They have got to go.
Phil martin, Wales
Yes I agree with everything that Tony Blair has done and said, and it's a shame that the news only reports the people that are against going to war. No-one wants to go to war but I really think that Tony Blair is justified in what he is doing.
Ann Clarke, England
My cousin is out there as part of the UK troop contingent. He has a wife and family like many of our boys in Kuwait. We should never have allowed this to get to this stage and we should not be going to war. If we are in a democracy then the people of this country should be given the chance to have a say. There are other ways of dealing with this and this is not one of them. I am against this war and our PM is WRONG.
Steve, UK
I am 100% behind Tony Blair and his stance on war against the world's biggest evil dictator. Saddam has not had days or weeks or months, but 12 years to comply and come clean. Who else would have been given this amount of time? No one. He should be taken out this time once and for all and let's all hope in the interests of the UK that the job is done properly this time and Saddam is gone forever.
Nick, UK
Great Britain should unite and show support to the brave men and women that go out to fight |
I believe the Commons did the right thing to stand with Mr Blair on this issue. No-one would voluntarily go to war with another country. I think Mr Blair has made a very tough decision and I think Great Britain should unite and show support to the brave men and women that go out to fight for our country. May they all return safely.
Jessica, Scotland Blair has no option now but to go to war. Inaction would show a weakness in the resolve of the UK and a demonstration of shallow threats. Members of the British public would criticise whatever the decision. A UN second resolution would have been the best option, but that was made unavailable by an obstinate French statement. How can Blair sit back now and let Saddam continue with his reign of terror? The hypocritical attitudes of some would shine through if inaction led to an attack on the UK. Now is the time to stand up and rid the world of a very real danger.
Elizabeth, Cardiff, UK
The first years of the third millennium will go down in history as the time when civilised men decided "enough is enough" and decided to do something about cancerous regimes. Hooray!
John Ingles, England
I am not happy with any Labour MP who voted against the government as I have not heard one good reason from any of them as to why war with Saddam should not take place. People who voted for Tony Blair will not stand by and allow some elements of the labour machine try and remove him.
peter b, UK
now is the time for unity and action, not division |
All the speeches that I heard last night finally persuaded me that the country's interests and safety come first. My belief in politics has been reinvigorated by the passionate arguments of BOTH camps. I felt proud to be part of this great nation and I firmly believe the government should now be supported 100%, now is the time for unity and action, not division.
Christopher, UK Those below who blame France seem to ignore all the countries NOT on the US list of the coalition of willing. We are not in the right and we do not have the broad international support that UK/US say we have. No REAL proof of the weapons of mass destruction. No mandate for war.
M. Jones, OXON, UK
Why is it that just because those that support war do not go onto the streets and parade they are seen as not interested? If pro-war demonstrations were to take place on our streets we would all be called racists and jingoists. The loyal support is behind Tony Blair. It is time for the silent majority to be heard. Whichever way that may be.
Ian Clark, Manchester UK
I am firmly in favour of what the prime minister is doing. We need to make a stand against dictators such as Saddam. The only effort he has made to disarm is when he has been back into a corner, and this is only to make a token gesture. We must let the troops know that we are behind them 100%.
Stephen Roper, England
No one wants war. But if the people of Britain were being treated the same way that Saddam Hussein is treating his people I would hope that some other country would step in and help us. I back Tony Blair all the way.
June Shillingford, British
He's damned if he does and damned if he doesn't |
I have always been uneasy about the reasons for war with Iraq but the troops have my full support. I can understand my MP (Bob Wareing) voting against the government and I won't hold it against him but my support is for the Prime Minister at this time; he's damned if he does and damned if he doesn't.
C Murray, United Kingdom Thankfully my local MP, Beverley Hughes, voted with the Prime Minister on this issue. Whether you agree with the war are not, the time for protest is over and everybody should get firmly behind the government. If the war goes badly - that is the time for ramifications, not before.
Patrick, England
My MP (Lib Dem) voted against the government but he had no more virtue than the Labour MPs who voted for the government. MPs following their Party's line are voting mainly for their jobs. This vote should have been a free vote and one of conscience. I find it difficult to believe than many British people can handle what's happening now with a clear conscience: it's at odds with the innate sense of justice and fair play which is at the heart of the British people.
John Macallister, UK
I have been living in Britain for many years now, and I am very proud of the British prime minister, sadly people here forgot how lucky they are to have democracy, jobs and stability in their lives. War is terrible, but sometimes the only solution. And it will be in my name. Our thoughts should be with people who will do this difficult job for us, while we sit and have civil decisions about what is good and bad. Tony Blair has my full support!
A Hodge, Poland
The country needs to back Tony Blair, and prove that we are united in the cause to rid the world of men like Saddam |
I think the country needs to back Tony Blair, and prove that we are united in the cause to rid the world of men like Saddam. World peace is the overall aim of everyone, but that goal cannot be achieved without first using force to remove those who are opposed to peace! I think that the country and the world should rally behind the British and American troops to solve the Iraq problem.
Martin, UK There is an old political wisdom that if you repeat a simple message enough times, the public will be hypnotised. And so "weapons of mass destruction" has become part of the language. But this war has much more to do with the concerns of a small lobby in Washington and nothing to do with morality. I am depressed at how many people believe the lies coming out of Washington and London. A depressing day for British democracy - once again the humble servant of America's corporate interests.
Neil Walker, London, UK
For those MPs who voted NO, because they thought this war immoral, would they still say it was immoral if a terrorist armed by Iraq attacked one of our cities with chemical weapons?
Gary, London, UK
Few MPs seem to understand that we can only sustain the troops on standby for a few weeks maximum due to logistical issues like aircraft and helicopter maintainability. It's either now or - literally - never. And if never, Saddam would throw out the inspectors and carry on, and no UN resolution could ever be enforced. I wouldn't have got here, since I wouldn't have started troop deployment, but there is more at stake now. My MP voted for the government and I reluctantly support him.
Charles, UK
I am totally behind the prime minister and I find it strange that, unlike a football match, all attention is focused on the loser's side instead of the winner's. Both pro and anti-war sides are claiming they speak for the majority of the country, so can we have a simple yes or no poll like CNN do to get a rough estimate how the UK stands?
Roy Sanders, England
It is good to see the democratic process in operation. With strong arguments both for and against. I believe that our MPs voted with integrity and conviction which ever way they voted. Nobody enters into war lightly.
Mark, UK
I am proud of those who withstood such pressure and voted against the government line |
A predictable result. Instead of a free vote, bully boy tactics were used by the whips to threaten and cajole MPs into voting according to the dictation of their leaders rather than their consciences. I am proud of those who withstood such pressure and voted against the government line. Many supporters of the war will claim this is democracy at work, but surely democracy is government of the people, by the people, for the people, and the final vote on the war does not reflect the opinion of the electorate. However, I am glad that a vote was held. The size of the vote against war must give Blair pause for thought.
N R Dove, UK I believe everything possible has been tried for peace. We have to make a stand now and I fully support Tony Blair and our troops. Good luck and God bless.
Margaret Trott, England
This action is probably as much a 9/11 revenge strike as anything else |
It is now probably too late to do anything but follow the USA into Iraq. However, this action is probably as much a 9/11 revenge strike as anything else, in order that the USA can clearly show all comers that it has the means and the will to destroy its perceived enemies, even if it chooses the politically disastrous path of hitting the wrong target with the wrong methods at the wrong time.
Terry Mills, UK MPs must have been worn down by Tony's unbelievable tenacity. I know I am.
Wendy, UK
Am I the only person who thinks that the people protesting outside Parliament are the same people sitting in trees next to airports? We are going to war. Let's support our men and have faith in our leaders.
Tim Parkinson, UK
I wonder what it will take for Tony Blair to understand that it is fundamentally wrong to go against over such vast number of rebelling MPs and, most importantly, to go to war without getting the consent of the nation? There are many frustrated citizens who are against the war and who are repeatedly being ignored by the government. What do these people need to do so that Tony Blair can get the message?
Yaprak Temren, Manchester, UK
I totally support Tony Blair. It is completely stupid not to realise that Saddam Hussein's regime is heading for world disaster. Past experience says that there is no other way to protect our way of life than removing Hussein now. One can only hope that it is not too late.
Jarek Rosinski, UK
Yes I am happy with how my MP, Martin Salter for Reading, voted. He is against this impending war with Iraq and quite rightly so, it is a total farce that the US and UK are going to war because Saddam Hussein has broke UN resolutions, yet we are going to war without a UN resolution. Nobody in their right mind disagrees that Saddam Hussein must be disarmed, but we are certainly going about this in the wrong way.
E. Jarvis, UK
This issue will not destroy the Labour party because we believe in a Labour government |
Our branch re-elected my Labour MP Tony McNulty last night in the knowledge that he would be voting with the government. Whilst I hate the idea of war I support his decision. This issue will not destroy the Labour party because we believe in a Labour government. Most activists are not single issue campaigners. Certain sectors of the press must think us pretty dumb if they seriously expect us to ditch the one party which can deliver a programme of social justice in the years ahead.
Pauline, London I am totally opposed to this war despite the propaganda machines efforts to change peoples minds. Thankfully my MP, Mohammed Sarwar, was one of the rebels but where were the rest? I naively thought that MPs are supposed to represent their constituents' views and I am sure many simply ignored them. It is tragic and illustrates it's a myth that we live in a democracy. God help the people of Iraq.
G. Harker, Scotland
Yes; Blair should be commended for continuing to support that which is necessary and ultimately morally correct.
Keith Picard, UK
My MP, the academic Dr Gibson, unfortunately was part of the rebel MPs. As an academic, he theorizes lots but has little experience in issues pertaining to the real world. I am all the more disappointed that he's been so vocal against the government and that he's spend much time protesting at the expense of the job he was elected to do. He was elected to Norwich, not to Iraq, and he has been neglecting the many problems that Norwich currently faces.
Shauna, Norwich, UK
If we were governed by these people that protest against action our country would be in a sorry state |
My Labour MP rebelled and I am not happy about that. Anyone that actually listened to Tony Blair in full yesterday must see action in the only sensible thing to do. If we were governed by these people that protest against action our country would be in a sorry state. I for one support Tony Blair.
Susan Campbell, Scotland The debate is now over. It is now time to stand by our armed forces and let them be in no doubt that they have our full support. I wish them Godspeed and I pray that they will return safely to their families after ridding the world of another evil person.
ALS, UK
People seem to suggest that now Parliament has decided we should all suddenly support the war, that those who do not can always vote out their MP in the next election, that this is what democracy is all about. This is NOT democracy; this is party politics. I do not support this war and do not support the troops - how can I, when I think that what they are doing is wrong?
Paul Stevens, UK
I have read the comments below with regard to this being a democracy. All we hear about is the thousands of people who have taken to the streets to protest against the war. What about all the millions of people who haven't? These are the people that although they do not like the idea of war they know it is the only way to get through to Saddam. Twelve years of talking has not made one bit of difference.
Margaret, UK
They're not supposed to ignore us and toe the party line or do whatever the PM wants |
Why are they called rebels? What's so brave about ignoring your constituents? I thought the whole point of democracy was that MPs are elected representatives of the people and represent what the people want. They're not supposed to ignore us and toe the party line or do whatever the PM wants. This is what passes for democracy these days, when millions of people take to the streets, and many millions don't agree from home, yet our 'representatives' seem to think this means "yes" to war. My faith in democracy has been shattered.
Alex, UK It's about time the government stopped their petty squabbling and got behind Tony Blair for the task in hand. Saddam has had more than enough chances and its now time for him to pay for all the suffering he has caused. I'm with Tony all the way!
P Stuart, UK
Yes the politicians were right to vote in support of our elected Prime Minister. Now democracy has triumphed, anyone not supporting our troops are a disgrace to this country.
Darren, UK
MPs are elected to voice the views of the people they represent who are clearly against a war |
What a joke of democracy we have. How can whips be used in a supposedly democratic country? MPs are elected to voice the views of the people they represent who are clearly against a war. Instead they allow themselves to be bullied into voting a different way. I shall not be voting for my MP again I encourage others to do the same. We cannot lecture other countries on democracy until we actually have it ourselves.
Ben Morgan, Wales Well done Mr Blair for putting the Great back into Britain!
Adrian English, Isle of Man
Democracy is not enough - we need morality as well in our political life, to blame the French because the whole of the rest of the world thinks we are unprincipled sods was the last disgusting spin in this sorry episode. I hope that a large number of these backboneless MPs get deselected before September, starting with the one from Sedgefield.
Anne, Wales UK
I think as a country we should support our leader |
I think as a country we should support our leader. Mr Blair is doing a great job in these times of crisis. Good luck to our soldiers and shame on those 'rebels' who voted against the government. As far as I am concerned Mr Blair; 'You CAN do it in my name'.
Tom Lawrence, UK Yesterday was a sad day for our so-called democracy. The people of Britain don't want it, the rest of the world don't want it but our MPs seem to think its in our nations interests - more like we don't want to upset the Americans. It's time that the people of this country and around the world stand up and tell the American and British governments to stop.
Ben Smith, England UK
The media has rightly focussed upon the division in the Labour Party in this debate. More importantly though the House of Commons has delivered the message to our troops and the world that they will support action against terror and rogue states and by a significant majority. War is not a question of party views but national interest.
Dave, London., UK
I'm really, really glad that my MP (Fabian Hamilton) was a rebel. I would have been horrified if I thought that someone I voted for could be a party to the destruction of tens of thousands of innocent Iraqi citizens.
Miriam, Leeds, UK
Last night MPs were rightly asked to stand up and be counted. Today I think we all should. I support the prime minister 100% - it's easy to walk away from difficult decisions. He hasn't and I respect that immensely.
Susan White, UK
Will people here stop saying we "all" support the war or we "all" don't support the war? Fact is some do, some don't and each side is scrambling for the moral high ground in a ridiculous fashion. I don't want a war but I equally resent being preached to by people who don't seem to be able to outline any clear alternative either. All everyone does on both sides is rant. And that precisely why this world is in such a mess!
Carl, UK
I regret to see that majority of MPs voted in favour of the war simply because they are afraid of losing their jobs.
Marilyn, UK
My local Conservative MP was one of the Tory rebels and I support his stance. The time is not right now to attack Iraq. None of us want to see our troops injured or killed, but that doesn't mean we have to suddenly and slavishly fall into line to back a policy that we don't believe in.
Andy Foster, UK
I wonder who said "United we stand, divided we fall"? Not 217 members of the Commons who I suspect would rather be tucked up in bed with a warm cup of cocoa whilst British soldiers do the work that those same 217 should have done with political persuasion a long time ago.
Harkess, Singapore
The British people want Saddam dealt with and the waiting over |
Chris Smith is my MP. I am not happy with the way he voted, the rebel MPs and much of the media is, in my opinion quite out of tune with how the majority of people feel. The protest in London was made up largely of the usual suspects who campaign on anything from fox hunting to anti-globalisation; their ranks were swelled by a good number of people from Europe. The British people want Saddam dealt with and the waiting over. The government now has very clear parliamentary support for military action.
Joseph Bowden, UK I'd like to ask the Stop the War Coalition who we should be listening to if not the 65% of elected MPs who don't agree with the rebels, the 73% of elected MPs who backed the government motion, the 52% of the population who do back the government, according to the latest polls, and the 98% of the population who HAVEN'T marched on the streets? They should realise their own view is not the be all and end all.
Rob Poll, London, England
How sad that so many MPs voted with the government when the biggest vote amongst the people are still against war. Tony Blair says we should rally around now - No - we live in a democracy. I have the right to express my view, which is; I support our troops, I do not want them to die, but I do not believe in the war. War will fuel hatred and ignite many new further conflicts in years to come - conflicts so large, the likes of which the world has never seen, let alone comprehend. I prey I'm wrong.
Richard Lee, UK
Where are the polls being taken we hear about where there are a lot of people against the war? Where i live the biggest majority is to get Saddam out. I back Tony and his party should do the same or resign. They are not helping our BRAVE troops.
Gilbert S Whyte, Scotland
I was disgusted with the way the vote went. I cannot comprehend how a Labour prime minister has aligned himself so wholeheartedly with one of the most extreme right wing leaders in the world. I find that the most frightening prospect of all. From a moral, political and historical point of view, we are in the most dangerous situation we have been in for years. I am proud of my MP, Graham Stringer, for standing up for the people of Manchester.
Sarah, UK
I am extremely proud of Tony Blair - he has shown outstanding bravery and leadership |
I am ashamed that my MP, Helen Clarke, did not support the government last night, and she certainly does not represent my views in this matter. I am extremely proud of Tony Blair - he has shown outstanding bravery and leadership during the last few months and exceptional patience with the UN members. We are entrusting our Government to act on our behalf - thank goodness we have Tony Blair and true democracy in this country.
Pat M, Peterborough, UK A decision has been made democratically in Parliament, with elected MPs voting the way they believe is right. If these MPs are wrong then they've fired the first shots of this war directly into their feet by alienating what the anti-war faction so strongly believes is a majority of constituents. If they're right, the Tories will be in next time, and not only will we be even more certain to go to war should this sort of situation arise again, but the country will be in a far worse economic state when we do it.
Roy, UK
The only reason the majority of MPs voted for the war is because they know that it has been imminent from as early as last July. They are too cowardly to vote against it because of the repercussions they might face. I wonder what repercussions the thousands of civilians will feel when we start our military assault on Iraq.
Adam, UK
If you understand something to be wrong, then voting in favour of it is a betrayal of one's own self. I believe that a large number of MPs have not only betrayed themselves but also their constituents. In the future it will be viewed that this war was the most undemocratic action in parliamentary history. What must be addressed is the right of one man to lead the country into this situation and then seek approval via an 11th hour debate.
John Pimm, UK
MPs have voted for their jobs rather than for their constituents |
A sad day for democracy. MPs have voted for their jobs rather than for their constituents or with their conscience. The issue has never been a War/No War one but whether Iraq is "sorted out" along with the Palestinian situation. Without the same vigorous attention given to Palestine our Parliament has sown the seeds of terrorism for a long time to come.
John M, UK A brave Commons did the right thing. Yes a second vote by the Security Council would have been the best option but let's not forget that that option was destroyed by the French. A nation who are prepared to undertake unnecessary nuclear tests in areas of world interest and have their special services sink the Rainbow Warrior make strange bedfellows for those who demand peace! It is right to stand up to Saddam now and liberate the Iraqis who have suffered at his hands for far too long.
Geoff, Wirral, UK
It's unfortunate that so many people currently equate courage and integrity with military action. I don't think it's particularly brave of any MP to wrap himself in the Union Jack, lambast those who oppose war at this stage for legitimate reasons, then vote to send others, my brother included, to fight a war for them. Labelling those who oppose military action at this time "appeasers" and "opportunists" is deeply offensive. I support my brother and his colleagues, but I think they were sent out too early to do a job only the majority of politicians wanted to see done now. Very sad.
Ed, UK
Once again the Tory party show how out of touch it is with the people, with only 15 rebels. I certainly won't be voting for them again.
Menno, UK
Although I think that a three line whip should not have been put on such an important matter, I believe the right decision has been taken. President Hussein has been in power not 12 years but 20 years too long.
Vijay, UK
Great Britain can be proud of Tony Blair, if he ever wants to relocate, we would welcome a man of such integrity. Too bad we don't have more politicians like him in America!
Gail Gaudreau, US
Good luck to all those who will go in harm's way to protect me and mine John Evans, Great Britain |
My MP voted with the government. Good. Hopefully we'll now hear less from the 'peace at any price' lobby and more from people who are actually prepared to act effectively to rid the world of a real danger. Good luck to all those who will go in harm's way to protect me and mine. You do it in my name - I'm proud of you.
John Evans, Great Britain I was disappointed to hear my local MP Frank Doran (Aberdeen Central) had rebelled against the prime minister. I believe those in protest are either blind to the truth or incredibly uninformed and should be supporting our military forces facing the near imminent action. With our help, the Iraqi people will be better off.
Nigel, Aberdeen, UK
It is a shame the level of information and debate on this matter has been so low. Before a democratic nation offensively attacks another sovereign state, without any direct provocation or indisputable evidence that there was going to be an attack, I would have expected a frank debate from the government and within the media. I am sorry that any MP supported the PM on this matter. We should not be going to war!
Dr David P Dolowitz, UK
Why do people keep going on about "Is this democracy?" Yes it is, a clear majority of MPs voted in favour of the resolution. If you don't like it, vote them out next time, at least you can, unlike the Iraq people. Time to make a stand; we are British not the Swiss.
Chris, England
I definitely think our prime minister should get the support of my MP. He certainly gets my full support. I was 7 years old when the Jackboot was driven out of my country (Jersey Channel Isles.) Despots like Saddam must not be allowed to continue. The silent majority like myself knows there comes a time when there is nothing left to say and action must be taken. Go for it Tony you have my support.
Rene Le Huquet, South Wales
Reading a lot of the comments here is very annoying. I resent being told that I, as a citizen of the UK, do not support war in Iraq. No large scale survey has taken place to accurately establish this country's view. I do support war as do nearly all of my friends and colleagues. I think it's time the anti-war "protestors" thought of a new, justified and accurate argument.
John, UK
Yes I think that MPs should be backing the prime minister in this and I'm happy they've voted the way they have done.
Chris Beenham, England
I fear our children will suffer the consequences |
As was said in the House, this will be a pre-emptive strike and as such, needs the backing of the international community. I fear our children will suffer the consequences of this war in years to come. The only way to deal with terrorism is to communicate, not bomb - although I have yet to see any evidence linking Iraq to international terrorism. A sad day.
Rachel, UK It is puzzling that the Commons has not understood the people of Britain who clearly do not support this action. Democracy has failed them. Blair and IDS will never be forgiven for this. The Isle of Man should now declare its disgust by declaring immediate independence from the UK and apply for separate UN membership as a sovereign state. We do not support any action taken without express UN approval.
Kevin Mort, Isle of Man
I now hope the British public will get behind and support our armed forces. |
Iraq's had 12 years to disarm and get its house in order. We cannot keep talking and talking action should be taken. I think most normal Iraqi's will be glad to see the back of Saddam. I now hope the British public will get behind and support our armed forces.
John Gillett, England It has depressed me so much that those we voted to represent us have not had the courage of their convictions tonight, and have ignored the voters. Expect many of them to loose their seats at the next election. They should all be ashamed of themselves.
Anna Johannessen-Adams, Wales
Blair's standing as a politician will depend on the outcome of the war and what comes after. I fear his prime motivation was simply to secure his place in history. He may be a hero equally he could be a devil
Chris, England
The people of Britain have been let down |
The people of Britain have been let down by the very people we have voted in. We pay taxes to pay for their wages yet they choose to ignore the people who marched against this. Democracy!
Tsunami, UK This is a very serious blow to the labour party and I also believe to Tony Blair's future in politics if the war doesn't turn out as he and his friend George Bush are predicting. This is also a serious blow to Britain's role in Africa especially because the continent has been consistent in their support for more time to the Weapons Inspectors and insisting on the role of the UN to lead and support and military intervention either in Iraq or elsewhere in the world where such intervention is necessary. What a sad day for the British people...
Masango, Cameroon
Look at the crowds in the streets - they express real feelings and attitudes |
Is that democracy? Look at the crowds in the streets - they express real feelings and attitudes, they show what the democratic majority wants. Blair and Bush and their likes are the biggest threats to democratic processes in the world. both of them bring shame on their nations.
Maciek, Poland Whether you believe in the war or were for or against in the vote, a haunting image for me will be MP's leaving the House laughing, smiling and joking after voting for action that demanded solemnity especially with the potential for loss of life on all sides
Dominique Egre, Jersey
Everyone knows it's not ideal, going to war. But there is no credible alternative. Let's hope it goes as well as war can go!!
Craig Balsillie, UK
Again politicians have proven the fact how different their views are, than those of the common voter... And yet at the next elections they will kiss our babies, make heroic speeches and beg us to vote for them - as they are representing us. Too bad voters forget too fast!
Alex, UK
I really believed we could stop this war. |
I really believed we could stop this war. So many of us expressed our disagreement. I am ashamed to be British but proud that my MP, Mark Lazarovich, voted against war.
Sue Kelly, Scotland I can only echo the view of Sue from Scotland. There was a while there that I thought the views of the public were going to be echoed in the commons. Thanks to the 'opposition' that wasn't to be. I am ashamed that Iraq will be invaded in my name but at least I can applaud my MP Mark Lazarowicz for voting against the action. There seems to be a misconception that to oppose military action is to somehow disown our troops. They are just doing a job and I fail to see why anyone should suddenly change their stance within the government on war in the name of 'supporting the troops'.
Dave Osborne, Scotland
Home
BBC NEWS CHANNEL
News services
Email this to a friend 
Printable version 
