Former News of the World editor Piers Morgan says his former paper acted responsibly in exposing the Duchess of York apparently trying to sell access to ex-husband Prince Andrew.
But former Daily Telegraph editor Sir Max Hastings says tabloid stings make him feel "creepy".
Watch the full debate at the Question Time website.
Or go directly to the part of the programme where the panel discussed the News of the World story.
Bookmark with:
What are these?
E-mail this to a friend