BBC NEWSAmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific
BBCiNEWS  SPORT  WEATHER  WORLD SERVICE  A-Z INDEX    

BBC News World Edition
 You are in: Programmes: Breakfast 
News Front Page
Africa
Americas
Asia-Pacific
Europe
Middle East
South Asia
UK
Business
Entertainment
Science/Nature
Technology
Health
-------------
Talking Point
-------------
Country Profiles
In Depth
-------------
Programmes
-------------
BBC Sport
News image
BBC Weather
News image
SERVICES
-------------
EDITIONS
BreakfastTuesday, 9 July, 2002, 04:49 GMT 05:49 UK
IVF mix-up heads for court
IVF
The clinic mixed donor samples
A judge may have to decide what happens to black twins born to a white couple after an apparent blunder at an IVF clinic.

It is possible that sperm from a black patient was used in error to fertilise eggs from the white woman, or that an embryo was implanted in the wrong woman.

Neither the people involved nor the clinic can be named, and a court hearing has been scheduled for October to consider the legal status of the babies. It is thought the couple want to keep the twins.

The case has prompted calls - including one from Labour peer and fertility expert Lord Winston - for tighter regulation to prevent a recurrence in the future.

News imageQ&A: IVF "mix-up" - click here.

A history of IVF

  • First test-tube baby born July 1978

  • Over one million IVF babies have been born worldwide

  • 27,000 couples in the UK have IVF treatment

  • 25 per cent of IVF procedures are successful

  • 8000 births a year are the result of fertility treatments


    Breakfast talked to Kate Brian has had two children using the IVF method. She has also written about it. She said:

    News image
    "This is going to have a big psychological impact."
    People are going to be worried about this story. There are already questions over embryos. Some of the women she has spoken to are worried about what happens to their spare eggs. There's a big psychological impact, IVF is already traumatic enough without this shadow being cast.

    Breakfast also talked to Barbara Hutchinson from the British Association for Adoption and Fostering. And to Clare Gorham, a black film maker and transracial adoptee.


    IVF involves mixing sperm from the man and eggs from the woman together in the laboratory, before they are placed in the woman.

    When the babies were born, the couple noticed that they were clearly dark-skinned, and suspected that something had gone wrong.

    Possible errors

    Professor Ian Craft, director of the London Fertility Centre, said mistakes have been made before.


    We just cannot afford to have these things happen

    Professor Ian Craft
    He said it was probably time for the regulatory body to consider tighter rules.

    "I have been aware of a situation at another centre whereby one couple received the wrong sperm from someone from a different ethnic group.

    "I fear that they might now be recommending that we have an extra layer of administration, but perhaps we should - we just cannot afford to have these things happen."

    Dr Vivienne Nathanson, of the British Medical Association, said that legally the woman who carries a child is the mother, regardless of its genetic inheritance.

    American baby

    An American mother, Donna Fasano of New York, gave birth to another couple's baby in 1998.

    Ms Fasano, who is white, gave birth to a black child and a judge ordered that she should hand the infant over to his biological parents.

    In Holland, suspicions were raised when a woman called Wilma Stuart, who is white, gave birth to dark-skinned twins in 1993.

    DNA tests showed the hospital had mistakenly mixed sperm from her husband with that of a black man from the Dutch Antilles. She kept the twins.

    The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority said inspections were regularly carried out to ensure that clinics met standards set out in its code of practice.

    "Clinical and scientific inspectors check that clinics have procedures in place to double-check the identification of the individuals undergoing treatment, the sperm and eggs at the time of insemination and the embryos and the patient at the time of embryo transfer."

  • Home
    When we are on air
    Recent forums
    Programme archive
    Studio tour
    Today's information
    MEET THE TEAM
    Presenters
    Reporters
    YOUR SAY
    Contact us
    Your comments
    See also:

    31 Mar 99 | Americas
    31 Mar 99 | Medical notes
    08 Jul 02 | Health
    08 Jul 02 | Health
    Internet links:


    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


    E-mail this story to a friend

    Links to more Breakfast stories

    © BBC^^ Back to top

    News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East |
    South Asia | UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature |
    Technology | Health | Talking Point | Country Profiles | In Depth |
    Programmes