| You are in: World: Europe | |||||||||||
| Monday, 8 October, 2001, 17:58 GMT 18:58 UK Analysis: Dangers on the ground ![]() Fog and pilot error are being blamed for the collision By BBC News Online's Sheila Barter The crash which has claimed more than 110 lives in Milan bears chilling resemblances to the world's worst-ever air accident - when two airliners collided in fog in the Canary Islands in 1977. Then, a KLM jumbo speeding its way to takeoff clipped a PanAm plane which was taxi-ing across the runway at Tenerife. In the blaze which followed, 583 people died. This time, it was a much smaller SAS plane taking off; a tiny German Cessna which was taxi-ing on the runway.
The answer - especially in fog - is frighteningly simple. If a pilot gets lost while taxi-ing around a complex airport system - as seems to have happened at Milan - the plane can simply wander on to the runway. Commercial licences In thick fog - and visibility at Milan was reportedly just 80m - even following the central taxi-ing or runway lights can be difficult. All pilots using the airport, even at the controls of a small plane, would have to hold commercial licences and be fully instrument-trained. They would also be following charts of the airport's taxi-ing and runway systems.
Normal pilots' protocol is to admit if you are lost and the vehicles will come and find you. That of course, only happens if you know you are lost in the first place, experts point out. The risk of pilots going astray is seen as greater at some of the world's most complex airports, says David Learmount of Flight International Magazine. Chicago, Atlanta and Dallas are among the world's trickiest - vast areas of tarmac, lights and taxi-ing systems. Milan's Linate is considerably easier - roughly equivalent in complexity to London Heathrow, said Mr Learmount.
In the conditions reported at Milan, pilots or air traffic controllers would have had no chance of seeing the impending tragedy. Everyone was operating "blind". "If conditions had been better, a sighting by one or both pilot would have been sooner rather than later, and the tragedy might have been avoided," said Richard Dawson, president of the Guild of Air Traffic Controllers. Lethal mix To add to the lethal mix of circumstances in Milan, the airport's ground radar system was not working. First reports said it had been turned off three days earlier for maintenance. But later it emerged that it was a year - possibly even two - since the radar had last been working. Italian unions, including the pilots' group, said the accident could have been avoided if the system had been on. But safety experts say the radar systems have their limits, and do not guarantee safety. Indeed, ground radar is not obligatory at airports.
But the absence of radar removes a crucial chance for a pilot's mistake to be spotted. "It should not be an accident waiting to happen, but the world being what it is, not having the system makes it easier for accidents to happen, especially at a busy airport," one industry source told BBC News Online.
The SAS pilot, accelerating towards take-off, appears to have swerved at the last minute as the Cessna suddenly loomed out of the fog. But by then a collision was unavoidable. The Italians have been quick to blame the German Cessna pilots for the tragedy, insisting they should not have been taxi-ing on the foggy runway. But the industry is cautious against rushing to judgment. Many past air accidents have turned out to have more complex causes than first appeared. In the tragedy at Tenerife, it was the PanAm pilot crossing the runway who turned out to be blameless. Instead, the crash was blamed on the KLM pilot , who had not checked he was cleared for take-off - and sped down the foggy runway to disaster. | See also: Internet links: The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites Top Europe stories now: Links to more Europe stories are at the foot of the page. | ||||||||||
Links to more Europe stories |
| ^^ Back to top News Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | In Depth | AudioVideo ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- To BBC Sport>> | To BBC Weather>> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- © MMIII|News Sources|Privacy | ||