Skip to main contentAccess keys help

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
News image
Last Updated: Tuesday, 3 October 2006, 09:39 GMT 10:39 UK
Press views: Turner Prize exhibition
Work by the four artists shortlisted for this year's Turner Prize has gone on display at the Tate Britain gallery in London.

But what do the critics have to say about nominees Tomma Abts, Phil Collins, Mark Titchner and Rebecca Warren?

Here is a round-up of some of the press reaction to the exhibition.

THE TIMES - DALYA ALBERGE

Teete 2003 by Tomma Abts
Tomma Abts was nominated for "intimate and compelling canvases"
If not for the exhibition labels, visitors to Tate Britain's latest show would never know that the nondescript office tucked away at the rear of a series of galleries was a work of art.

Nor would they realise that a cherry stone, a dirty cotton-wool ball and other bits of debris in a display case were a sculpture.

But these are exhibits in the Turner Prize 2006 exhibition, and curators are once again courting controversy.

DAILY MIRROR - TOM PARRY

An installation by Rebecca Warren
Installations by Rebecca Warren include rubbish found on her floor
There are already plenty of people out there who think modern art is a load of rubbish.

And here's one artist who seems determined to prove it really is a waste.

Turner Prize contender Rebecca Warren has filled five display cases with dross she found on her studio floor and the road outside.

Curator Lizzie Carey-Thomas declared: "They have emotional and associative resonance, and can communicate meaning."

Let's hope that's cleared things up for those of you who actually thought it was just a pile of litter.

THE SUN - 'TOULOUSE LE PLOT'

Ergo Ergot by Mark Titchner
Mark Titchner creates paintings, light boxes and animations
Warren's clay sculpture explodes out of, then merges back into, the amorphous properties of the material.

That's why it looks all lumpy.

Tate spin doctors say artist Mark Titchner uses "optical illusion to emphasise the fragility of our senses".

I should have gone to Specsavers.

THE GUARDIAN - ADRIAN SEARLE

The best I can say about Titchner's work is that it looks bizarre.

It's all too clever by half, I keep thinking: too many complications, too much self-conscious eccentricity.

Why must Warren always make a joke out of her sculptures? The more I am meant to pick up the references in Warren's art... the less interested I become. There's too much rhetoric.

[Tomma] Abts and [Phil] Collins are the most developed in my view. They ought to win.

DAILY TELEGRAPH - NIGEL REYNOLDS

Shady Lane Productions by Phil Collins
Artist Phil Collins has produced the first ever "live" Turner Prize exhibit
The biggest talking point is likely to be generated by a work that could have been crafted by Harold Pinter for the theatre.

A large room looking exactly like an office in which three or four people will sit and work, answering phones, tapping into computers, every weekday until 14 January between 10am and 6pm.

Was this art? Yes, definitely, because the artist said so, explained Katherine Stout, one of the curators.




SEE ALSO
Turner Prize work goes on display
02 Oct 06 |  Entertainment
In pictures: Turner Prize exhibition
02 Oct 06 |  In Pictures
Profiles: Turner Prize nominees
16 May 06 |  Entertainment
Turner Prize shortlist announced
16 May 06 |  Entertainment



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

PRODUCTS & SERVICES

AmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific