Skip to main contentAccess keys help

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Monday, 20 September, 2004, 05:42 GMT 06:42 UK
Court ditches Qantas-Air NZ deal
Qantas jet over Sydney
The deal means the two airlines will have to fend for themselves
A planned tie-up between Australia's Qantas and Air New Zealand has been thrown out by New Zealand's High Court.

The decision ends a two-year effort by the airlines to fight off low-cost carriers by combining forces.

Both countries' competition watchdogs had rejected the deal, arguing that the reduction in consumer choice had outweighed the benefits.

Although the parties have 20 days to appeal, Qantas said it now wanted to "move on".

The decision "ignores major structural changes" in the industry worldwide, said the Australian airline's chief executive, Geoff Dixon.

"Today's decision... contrasts with the marked trend toward consolidation."

It is disappointing that Air NZ and Qantas were not allowed to introduce some rationality into a market that has been anything but rational
Air New Zealand

KLM and Air France had been allowed to merge, he pointed out, while British Airways had sold its 18% stake in his company earlier in September so as to ease its participation in Europe's "inevitable consolidation".

The deal would have given Qantas a 22.5% stake in Air NZ in exchange for NZ$550m (US$363m; �202m), and led to co-operation on routes between the countries and within New Zealand.

Threat

Both Air NZ and Qantas have experienced the same pressure from budget carriers as their peers elsewhere in the world.

Virgin Blue and Emirates Air, among others, are flying many Australasian routes.

Qantas has launched two low-cost carriers of its own to help it hang onto its market.

For Air NZ, the final collapse of the proposed deal threatened its long-term survival, the airline said.

"It is disappointing... that the court has not allowed Air NZ and Qantas to take this opportunity to introduce some rationality into a market that in recent years has been anything but rational," it said in a statement.

'Detriments'

But the Commerce Commission in New Zealand had disagreed, finding negative effects of between NZ$195m and NZ$466m.

The court concurred.

"The appellants have not shown the Commission to have erred in concluding that the likely public benefits of the proposed alliance would not outweigh the likely efficiency detriments," it said.

Air NZ made a net profit of NZ$166m in the year to June.


SEE ALSO:
BA to sell off 18% Qantas stake
08 Sep 04  |  Business
'Damn you Qantas' says Gold Coast
15 Apr 04  |  Business
Qantas in Singapore low-cost deal
06 Apr 04  |  Business
Qantas has an unexpected profit
19 Feb 04  |  Business
New blow for Qantas-NZ deal
23 Oct 03  |  Business


RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
AmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific