BBC NEWSAmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia PacificArabicSpanishRussianChineseWelsh
BBCiCATEGORIES  TV  RADIO  COMMUNICATE  WHERE I LIVE  INDEX   SEARCH 

BBC NEWS
 You are in:  Business
News image
Front Page 
World 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Market Data 
Economy 
Companies 
E-Commerce 
Your Money 
Business Basics 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 
News image


Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

SERVICES 
Wednesday, 24 April, 2002, 15:19 GMT 16:19 UK
'Misleading' food producers named
Person shopping
Consumers' Association is running an 'honest labelling' campaign
Food manufacturers who make confusing and sometimes misleading claims about their products, have been 'named and shamed' by the Consumers' Association.

The move follows notification by the shopper's watchdog last month that it would publish a list as part of its "honest labelling" campaign.

'Named and shamed'
Heinz ham sandwich filler - contains 20% ham
Bernard Matthews chicken breast - 62% chicken
Princes Crab paste - 39% mackerel, 20% cod, 11% crab
Knorr Taste Breaks pasta (creamy chicken and herb) contains 1% chicken
  Click here to see more products Source: Consumers' Association

The body found that phrases such as "farm fresh", "fat free" and "lite" were often misleading, and it now wants the European Union to impose stricter regulations.

Researchers who examined dozens of pre-packaged found that McVitie's Butter Puffs did not contain butter; Heinz ham sandwich filler contained only 20% ham; and Ocean Spray Pure Juice Cranberry with grape and apple, had more grape in it than cranberry.

Unclear labels

Under current rules, manufacturers do not have to tell customers about all of the ingredients they use.

Consumers' Association Campaign
Nutrition claims should be defined in legislation
Crackdown on references to health benefits as a marketing gimmick
Information about the origin of ingredients and products to be as comprehensive and specific as possible
Consumers need to know if GM derived ingredients have been used, for example, soya oil
Provide information about nutrition

For example, Golden Wonder does not list salt or sodium as an ingredient on its prawn cocktail flavour crisps, but Golden Wonder confirmed to researchers that they did contain salt in the flavouring.

Even where guidelines had been issued, manufacturers continued to flout them, the research said.

"Low fat" according to the former Food Advisory Committee, a committee of the Food Standards Agency, should mean that the product has less than 3g of fat per 100g.

But consumers said that they find the term "% fat-free" confusing.


UK food and drink manufacturers rely on the loyalty and trust of their customers and in no way set out to mislead

Food and Drink Federation

Researchers found that products which could be viewed as a healthy option by consumers had high fat contents. For example, Walkers Lites!, a low-fat brand of crisps, still had a 22% fat content.

Sheila McKechnie, director of Consumers' Association, said: "Some manufacturers are getting away with seriously misleading descriptions about the contents of their food products.

"They must stop trying to fool consumers and be more honest about their goods.

"Healthy diets are a very important issue. Food-related disease is a priority and at the moment it is more important than food safety."

But The Food and Drink Federation, a food manufacturers industry body, said that the food industry was already working with the Food Standards Agency to improve food labelling.

Deputy Director General Martin Paterson, said: "UK food and drink manufacturers rely on the loyalty and trust of their customers and in no way set out to mislead.

"They do have to get across as much information to consumers on what can sometimes be a very small space.

"Industry agrees that marketing claims and labelling should be truthful and not misleading."

  • Low fat claims
  • Walkers Lites! - Advertised as 33% less fat, but still contains 22% fat, so not a product low in fat
  • Sainsbury's Be Good to Yourself 2 Garlic Baguettes - '25% less fat' on the label - but still contains 14% fat (11.9g per half baguette)
  • Yeo Valley Organic healthy eating cr�me fraiche (Yeo Valley Organic Company) - Claims to be 'healthy', but contains 17.5% fat
  • Spam Lite and Spam (Tulip International) - 'Lite' version contains 17% fat. 'Lite' version claims to have 25% less fat and salt, but normal version has no nutrition labelling, so impossible to compare
  • Asda Ham and Mustard Quiche - Part of their 'Good for You' range, but still contains 11% fat and 47% of calories in this product are from fat

    • Ingredients
  • McVitie's Butter Puffs - Contain no butter, just vegetable oil
  • Vale Fine Foods Fresh Sandwich Filler - Tuna and Sweetcorn (Zorba chilled foods) - Main ingredient is mayonnaise
  • Bernard Matthews chicken breast - (Bernard Matthews Foods Ltd) - only 62% chicken
  • Princes Crab paste - More mackerel (39%), cod (20%), and water, than crab (11%)
  • Safeway Tuna and Onion paste - Also contains 20% cod
  • Safeway Salmon and shrimp paste - More mackerel (30%), cod (15%) and water than shrimp (3%)
  • Safeway chicken and vegetables savoury rice - Contains 82% rice, 6% dried vegetables, chicken is unquantified, but appears near the bottom of the list just before herbs and herb extracts
  • Paxo Celebration sausagemeat and thyme - Ingredients in order are: rusk, wholemeal breadcrumbs, mechanically recovered dried turkey (minimum 8%)
  • Sainsbury's special recipe stuffing mix, sausagemeat - Ingredients in order are: rusk, breadcrumbs, dried turkey powder (8.5%).
  • Pure (spread) (Matthews foods plc) - 'Pure' has a picture of a sunflower on the front, but also contains palm oil. Contains 55% sunflower oil
  • Fruit Bowl fruit flakes (Stream Foods Ltd) - Claims to be 'natural colour, good for energy, low in fat', but doesn't mention that it is high in sugar (80g per 100g)
  • Heinz ham sandwich filler - contains 20% ham. Water is the main ingredient
  • Ocean Spray Pure Juice Cranberry with Grape and Apple (Gerber Foods Soft Drinks Ltd) - Contains 50% grape, 28% apple, and 22% cranberry.

    • Confusing product pictures
  • Dolmio Carbonara - No nutrition labelling. Also, picture of whole cheese on front of product, but only contains cheese powder
  • Knorr Tastebreaks Pasta Carbonara (Bestfoods UK Ltd) - Large pieces of ham shown on product label, but only contains 1.2% cured ham
  • Knorr Taste Breaks pasta, creamy chicken and herb (Bestfoods UK Ltd) - Chicken features significantly in picture on label, but product contains only 1% chicken.

    Source: Consumers' Association

      Click here to return

  •  WATCH/LISTEN
     ON THIS STORY
    News image The BBC's Philippa Busby
    "Shoppers are quite healthily aware about the whole business"
    See also:

    04 Apr 02 | Business
    'Dishonest' food labels exposed
    Internet links:


    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

    Links to more Business stories are at the foot of the page.


    E-mail this story to a friend

    Links to more Business stories



    News imageNews image