| You are in: World: Americas | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Monday, 5 February, 2001, 14:34 GMT Lockerbie: Long road to legal claim ![]() Relatives are still fighting for justice By BBC News Online's Kevin Anderson in Washington Lawyers representing the US relatives of victims in the Lockerbie bombing are pursuing legal proceedings in multi-billion dollar claims against the Libyan Government. In two separate suits, relatives of the victims are seeking $10bn (�6.7bn) and $20bn (�13.4bn) in damages. Efforts had been suspended pending the outcome of possible appeal proceedings at the criminal trial in the Netherlands. But lawyers involved in both suits say that the conviction of Libyan intelligence agent Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed Al Megrahi for the 1988 bombing is key to their case. The proceedings will be greatly complicated by the fact that the civil case is not against an individual or corporation but a foreign government. � Case histories Lawyer Mark Zaid filed the first civil suit against the Libyan Government in 1993. Before that time, most of the families had been involved in civil lawsuits against Pan American Airlines.
In 1997, the Supreme Court let stand a lower court ruling that Libya could not be the subject of a civil lawsuit, saying that a foreign government has sovereign immunity shielding it from such suits. � However, due to pressure from the families of Lockerbie victims, the United States amended the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act in 1996, opening the way for civil suits against foreign governments in certain cases - including acts of terrorism. � Following the passage of the Anti-Terrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act in 1996, many families of Lockerbie victims renewed their suits. � In 1999, the US Supreme Court heard another case involving a civil suit against Libya in connection with the Lockerbie bombing, and based on the change in the law, the court ruled that families of the Lockerbie victims could proceed with their case seeking damages from Libya. � Sending a message In asking for $20bn in damages, Mr Zaid said the families want the Libyan Government to be held responsible for what they allege is the nation's involvement in the bombing.
If successful, the suits would represent some of the largest awards ever resulting from civil cases. � In July 1999, General Motors was ordered to pay $4.9bn as a result of a suit brought by six burn victims who were disfigured in crashes involving GM cars. It was the largest award in a product liability suit up to that time. By comparison, in the civil lawsuit against OJ Simpson regarding the deaths of his ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman, the jury awarded $8.5m to the Goldman family. But the award against GM was soon eclipsed when a Florida jury ordered tobacco companies to pay $145bn to sick smokers in the state. The suit is likely to be tied up in appeals for years. Complicated case
However, unlike these product liability suits, the families of Lockerbie victims face unique challenges in bringing their cases, said Peter Buscemi, a lawyer with the Washington DC law firm Morgan, Lewis & Bockius. � Mr Buscemi is a former assistant to the Solicitor General in the US Department of Justice, and he has been involved with a variety of civil litigation. � A civil suit against a foreign government entails a whole series of issues in addition to those faced in typical civil suits, he said. � In a typical civil case, plaintiffs can ask the defendants to turn over documents, provide witnesses and respond to written questions during what is called the discovery process. But in the cases brought by the Lockerbie families, said Mr Buscemi, there is a question of whether Libya will be willing to subject itself to demands from courts in the US. � And even if a judgement is obtained, there is the question of obtaining compensation. � It is pretty straightforward when suing General Motors or Joe Smith, said Mr Buscemi, but not quite so easy when dealing with a foreign government. |
See also: Internet links: The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites Top Americas stories now: Links to more Americas stories are at the foot of the page. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Links to more Americas stories |
| ^^ Back to top News Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | In Depth | AudioVideo ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- To BBC Sport>> | To BBC Weather>> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- © MMIII|News Sources|Privacy | ||