BBC HomepageWorld ServiceEducation
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: World: Africa
News image
Front Page 
World 
Africa 
Americas 
Asia-Pacific 
Europe 
Middle East 
South Asia 
-------------
From Our Own Correspondent 
-------------
Letter From America 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 
News image


The BBC's Mark Doyle reports
Part One: The victim's story
 real 28k

Special report
Part Two: What the future holds
 real 28k

Thursday, 10 February, 2000, 13:11 GMT
Peace without justice in Sierra Leone
Sierra Leonean baby
No justice for those who suffered at rebel hands
By West Africa correspondent Mark Doyle in Sierra Leone

The United Nations has begun deploying in Sierra Leone what could become its largest peacekeeping force anywhere in the world.

The force will monitor a controversial peace agreement which gives an amnesty to rebels who committed widespread atrocities against civilians.

The deployment is the first major test for the UN in Africa after a series of failures in other parts of the continent.

It also coincides with a challenge to the main faction leader, Foday Sankoh, who led the rebellion, but who is now portraying himself as a peacetime leader who wants to end Sierra Leone's endemic corruption.

Diamonds

Foday Sankoh has announced that all illegal diamond mining should stop and that anyone who contravenes this will be arrested.
Baby's severed limb
What will he ask when he grows up?
Although the implementation of this order will undoubtedly prove difficult, the announcement goes to the heart of the issues which sparked the decade-long war.

The rebellion in Sierra Leone was financed by illegal diamond mining.

Millions of dollars worth of gemstones were smuggled out of the country every day - most of them to Liberia, which borders the rebel-held areas of Sierra Leone.

Before the war, corruption and mismanagement in the diamond sector was one of the main reasons why Sierra Leone became, on UN figures, the poorest country in the world.

Indeed, Foday Sankoh says fighting corruption was the motivation for his rebellion. He insists that he has not personally enriched himself with diamonds, and on a recent tour of the eastern region repeatedly said, in the Krio language: "No rebel no dig no diamond."

Mr Sankoh's public commitment to stop illegal diamond mining could show how serious he is about fighting corruption. It could also be a test of his authority over his men and the region they control.

A 5,000-strong UN force has already been deployed in the Sierra Leone capital Freetown and some other parts of the country to monitor the peace deal. But the UN has yet to send a significant number of troops to Foday Sankoh's stronghold.

Minerals chief

As part of the peace agreement signed by the government and rebels last year, Sankoh was appointed Chairman of the Strategic Minerals Commission.
Foday Sankoh
Rebel leader Foday Sankoh: Denies responsibility for massacres
This is a key post which should oversee the rational exploitation of Sierra Leone's diamond wealth for the benefit of the population - rather than for benefit of smugglers and corrupt politicians as is the case now.

Government negotiators at the peace talks last year said Foday Sankoh was given the job in order to tempt him into signing the peace deal.

The government also agreed, in exchange for peace, to a controversial amnesty for rebels who committed atrocities against civilians.

Many Sierra Leoneans were outraged at the deal - they said the amnesty and Mr Sankoh's appointment as diamond overlord appeared to reward the rebels.

But others said any deal was preferable to a war which has displaced millions of people and seen some of the worst atrocities committed anywhere in the world.

Infant victim

Fourteen-month-old Abu Sesay is the youngest known victim of the rebel atrocities.
Tenneh Cole
Tenneh Cole: Forced to flee orphanage
A year ago, when Abu was two months old, the rebels invaded Freetown and tried to overthrow the government. Thousands of innocent people were killed before Nigerian-led troops of the west African intervention army, Ecomog, expelled the rebels from the city.

Thousands of people were deliberately mutilated by the rebels - including Abu, then just two months old, who had his right foot hacked off.

The atrocities against civilians appear to have been committed as a warning to others not to support the elected government.

Another victim of the war was Tenneh Cole. She was born nine years ago when the war began. In 1996 Tenneh became a media celebrity when she was taken to Britain by charity workers to remove a bullet from her head.

Her life was successfully saved by surgeons at Norwich Hospital, but the bullet wound, and other medical complications, left Tenneh deaf and partially sighted.

Rare happy ending

Recently the BBC has met Tenneh again. In the last few years she was forced to flee her orphanage twice because of rebel attacks and take refuge in the bush.
X-ray photo
A bullet lodged in Tenneh's skull has impaired her vision and hearing
But this is one Sierra Leonean story that, for now, has a happy ending. Tenneh is living with a loving foster family in Freetown and we found her excited by her first day at a school for the hearing impaired.

The deaf school was looted during the war and now manages without electricity or properly trained teachers. The school cannot afford a single hearing aid - although these only cost a few dollars each.

Many of the children at the school are deaf as a direct result of the war and the poverty it exacerbated. A large proportion of them contracted deafness through Lassa fever, a disease spread by rodents that thrive in unsanitary slums.

But the children are working hard despite their handicaps. When we visited the school they were learning a sign-language version of the Sierra Leonean national anthem.

Challenge to UN

While the promise by Foday Sankoh to bring illicit mining under control is a test for him, the United Nations is also facing a severe challenge in Sierra Leone.

Some 5,000 peacekeepers have already been deployed to monitor the peace deal. But UN Secretary General Kofi Annan wants the force to be doubled in size, which would make it the world's largest UN peacekeeping operation.
UN vehicle
The UN plans to double its force to 11,000
In recent years the UN has been humiliated in Africa. Peacekeeping operations in Somalia, Rwanda and Angola failed to stop the wars there.

The experience in Rwanda in 1994, was the lowest point of all: a series of catastrophic errors and failures saw UN troops withdraw while genocide took place.

Kofi Annan takes some personal responsibility for this failure as he was Head of UN Peacekeeping at the time of the genocide.

As long as there is the political will among Sierra Leonean faction leaders - principally Foday Sankoh - to maintain the peace, the UN could succeed in its mission to bolster the peace agreement.

Enough soldiers?

But unless the troop strength is brought up to the full 10,000 that Mr Annan wants, the first signs of any military challenge to the UN could prove disastrous.
Mutilation victim
Thousands of people were mutilated by rebels
The UN force in Sierra Leone is mainly made up of Indian, Kenyan and Nigerian troops.

But the Nigerians - who are there as a follow-up to Ecomog - now want to go home. Without them, the UN force probably could not stand up to any military challenge the Sierra Leonean factions could mount in the event of them returning to war.

The United Kingdom's Minister for African Affairs, Peter Hain, who visited Sierra Leone this month, said it was essential that the spectre of UN failures in Africa be redressed.

Mr Hain conceded that the peace agreement which gave amnesty to the Sierra Leone rebels for atrocities they had committed "is not an agreement of which any of us can be immensely proud".

Compromises

But he said the agreement was the best available, and had to be made to work. He compared compromises made for peace in Sierra Leone with compromises the UK made with the IRA in Northern Ireland.

Sierra Leone has peace without justice. But since no major Western power wanted to intervene against the war crimes committed there - unlike in Bosnia or Kosovo - this appears to be the only peace it will get.

The key question now is whether the controversial peace deal and amnesty will create a cycle of impunity which could encourage new rebellions - or whether the compromise will hold.

News imageSearch BBC News Online
News image
News image
News imageNews image
Advanced search options
News image
Launch console
News image
News image
News imageBBC RADIO NEWS
News image
News image
News imageBBC ONE TV NEWS
News image
News image
News imageWORLD NEWS SUMMARY
News image
News image
News image
News image
News imageNews imageNews imageNews imagePROGRAMMES GUIDE
Africa Contents
News image
News imageCountry profiles
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

News image
Links to other Africa stories are at the foot of the page.
News image

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Africa stories



News imageNews image