EuropeSouth AsiaAsia PacificAmericasMiddle EastAfricaBBC HomepageWorld ServiceEducation
News image
News image
News image
News imageNews image
News image
Front Page
News image
World
News image
UK
News image
UK Politics
News image
Business
News image
Sci/Tech
News image
Health
News image
Education
News image
Sport
News image
Entertainment
News image
Talking Point
News image
News image
News image
On Air
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help
News imageNews imageNews image
News imageTuesday, December 1, 1998 Published at 11:43 GMT
News image
News image
Get the balance right
News image
Dickie Bird: 'There is light in the tunnel'
News image
In the fourth of Dickie Bird's exclusive reports, the former umpire and best-selling author looks at why England lost at Perth.

England's performance in Perth was disappointing, although knowing the pitch there not entirely a shock.

But it was not all bad. One good thing that came out of the match was the performance of young Alex Tudor.


[ image: Alex Tudor should play in the next match]
Alex Tudor should play in the next match
I said I would play him in Perth because of the extra pace and bounce and I was proved right.

He did very well on his test debut, and now I just hope can keep fit and keep himself going.

I would pick him again for Adelaide - you have got to encourage players like that because I think England have got a good prospect.

Darren Gough also bowled well for England. I knew he would do well because he is a tremendous competitor and will keep going all the time.

He hasn't had a lot of luck in this series, and has suffered from dropped catches off his bowling.

In fact England have dropped too many catches - it's very important, crucial in fact that you take your chances when they are offered.

Fielding practice

What people don't realise is that when you play abroad the ball comes a lot quicker through the air than in England.

You may be in the outfield and think you are judging a catch perfectly but the next thing you know the ball has flown over your head.

It is essential that you concentrate on fielding practice abroad and I'm sure England will be doing just that.

But the missed chances did not actually lose England this second Test.

It was lost when they did not score enough runs in the first innings - if you get bowled out for 112 in the first innings of a Test you've got a fight on to your hands to win the match.

I'm not blaming anyone for that - the level of the first innings collapse did surprise me but knowing Perth as I do, I have seen many sides bowled out there simply because of the pace and bounce the pitch offers.

All rounder

A lot of people have criticised the lower order batting but the problem runs deeper than that - the most crucial position in the England team is not filled.


[ image: England still haven't replaced this man]
England still haven't replaced this man
England have not had a genuine all-rounder since Ian Botham retired.

If you look at all the great Test sides back in history they have had players like Botham.

The West Indies had Gary Sobers, while the Aussies have been lucky enough to have not one but two Waugh twins in recent years.

People say Alec Stewart fills the role but he will say himself that he is not a true all-rounder.

He has to keep wicket because it is the only way England can compensate for the absence of someone who can score a hundred and then take five wickets.

Having a good all rounder gives your team balance, and not having one puts a lot of pressure on the tail-end batsmen.

As far as the top order, experience tells me that the Aussies are deciding in their team meetings to target England's most experienced players - Stewart and Mike Atherton.

And they're getting them cheaply, putting a lot of pressure on the rest of the batting.


[ image: Graeme Hick has given the selectors a problem]
Graeme Hick has given the selectors a problem
Graeme Hick has now put a lot of pressure on England selectors.

I'm a big fan of John Crawley, who I thought was the best English batsman on the county circuit last season.

I'd be looking to play the Lancastrian in every Test but that is very difficult now with Hick's performance, although for once this is a good problem for the selectors to have.

Having said that, it is crucial Graham Thorpe comes back - injury permitting.

He's a very important part of the order because it gives England two left handers in their top six, a situation which can unsettle the line of the bowlers.

Aussie strength

The Aussies prove that point with Mark Taylor and Justin Langer, not to mention world class players in reserve like Darren Lehmann, Michael Bevan and Matthew Elliot.

Their batting is very powerful and they are simply the best side in the world. I was not surprised they stood up to the Perth pitch better than England.


[ image: Jason Gillespie was magnificent in Perth]
Jason Gillespie was magnificent in Perth
Their bowlers were also able to exploit the conditions fully, particularly Jason Gillespie, who certainly looks to have got over his fitness worries.

What he does is swing it away from the bat late, which gets good players out particularly on a pitch like Perth. He bowled magnificently but can he keep it up for the rest of series?

England have to keep going, and I believe they must return to playing five bowlers.

Playing seven batsmen in Perth was a mistake - to win Test matches you have to bowl sides out twice, and need the bowlers to do so.

There is hope

Having said all that I can see light in the tunnel for England - mainly thanks to that storm in Brisbane which saved them from a 2-0 deficit.

Adelaide - the next venue - represents their best chance to win a match.

It's a good pitch and England should not lose there. They could even win, but only if they pick five bowlers.

News image


Advanced options | Search tips


News image
News image
News imageBack to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage |
News image

News imageNews imageNews image
News imageNews image
Relevant Stories
News image
01 Dec 98�|�England on Tour
Time to attack
News image
30 Oct 98�|�England on Tour
Dickie down under
News image

News image
News image
News image
News imageIn this section
News image
Plucky England hang around
News image
Solanki breathes life into draw
News image
Headley on the mend
News image
Black player drafted for England match
News image
England crank up the pace
News image
Butcher beefs up England total
News image
England 'A' ease to victory
News image
England scramble to a draw
News image
Butcher facing chop
News image
Caddick lone England star
News image
Neale gets England 'fixer' role
News image
Hussain secures first Tour victory
News image
England flop in tour opener
News image
Bangladesh hold out for draw
News image
New-look England jet off
News image
Boo-boo aims for error-free ride
News image
'Think tank' role for Atherton and Stewart
News image
Hansie Cronje: Captain on trial
News image
Kirtley called up for A tour
News image
England player profiles
News image
South Africa player profiles
News image
Hamilton switches sides
News image
A captain in the making
News image
Second time lucky for Maddy
News image
England need Swann to strutt
News image
South African Test venues
News image

News image
News image
News image